MovieChat Forums > Soldier's Girl (2003) Discussion > A personal perspective. . .

A personal perspective. . .


I am a woman, who happens to be transsexual. I am married (yes, married) to a wonderful man who I've been with since 2002, even while I was pre-op. Finally I got a chance to watch this movie tonight.

My husband and I watched it together, and it hit home in more ways then one. My husband was appalled at the disregard for privacy, and human life in general. He realized that had the wrong people found out about our own relationship, he could very well have been Barry.

The scene where Callie was standing in front of the mirror with her robe opened was extremely moving for me. It brought back many memories of how I had hated seeing myself in a mirror, the utter disgust at my body being what it was. Lee Pace did an excellent job of portraying that same disgust to the viewer. Or perhaps it was something only seen by people who knew what that situation felt like. I'm not sure exactly. My husband could recall seeing that same look in my eyes whenever I caught a glimpse of my body when I was pre-op.

I really wish that this tragic situation had been used more to spread information about transsexuality rather than homosexuality though. I know that Barry was murdered because he was perceived to be gay; and indeed, perhaps he was but didn't realize it himself yet. We will never know. I don't personally believe he was, though. If the passion between Troy and Lee on-screen was even half of what it was between Barry and Callie in real-life, I don't think anyone could mistake them for a gay couple. There was just too much of a mixture of raw masculine/feminine/man/woman/boy/girl passion there to mistake it for anything but. It was clear that Barry made Callie feel like a total woman, regardless of what might still have been between her legs. I know that my husband, accepting me as 100% woman, helped give me the self-confidence I needed to get through every day before I was lucky enough to get the gender reassignment surgery over with.

This movie was heartwrenching. I cannot comprehend how Callie must have felt when she heard on the news about Barry's death. The thought of losing the man I love in that way is so unbearable that I am afraid to let myself think about it. What is terribly sad is that another man, who is confident enough in himself to accept a woman like Callie, and myself, and all other transsexual women out there, for the woman that she is, not the "man" that she was, is gone. In my experience, there aren't many men out there like that. Far too many wanted me because I was pre-op transsexual, and quite frankly, it was rather disgusting.

reply

Your post brought tears to my eyes! Thank you and I hope more people read this and see the sincerity in your words.

reply

[deleted]

I'm also transsexual. I have to say, I had precisely the same reaction to what I saw in the movie as you did. I wondered the same thing about the scene where Calpernia stares at her body in the mirror, pre-op - wondered whether non-transsexuals would realize how perfectly Lee Pace did that, where if you know what it feels like, you know exactly what the character is feeling.

I can relate to everything you're talking about in your post, not wanting to be wanted as a pre-op transsexual, wanting to be wanted as a woman. I'm glad you found someone who could see you for what you are; I'm with someone right now who seems to be able to see me the same way.

Thanks for your post.

reply

As a transgendered person who is currently debating his/her future as a transsexual, both this movie and your post were very welcome additions to my ever convoluted through process right now. In general, thank you for the courage of all those who have come before.

reply

You are a beautiful person Shayna

reply

Thank you for the lovely post Shayna.

Many happy years to you and your wonderful husband.

~Spirit desire, spirit desire, we will fall.~

reply

Wow... I'm glad your post didn't bring the crazies out.

I think everyone can find something to relate to in Pace's performance... As a woman I don't know a single friend who's not hated her body at one point or another so I can't imagine what it feels like to be in a situation like yours but I think the movie shone a brief light on those feelings and did so tactfully and with love for the human beings in the story, regardless of their gender, orientation or identity crisis and that's why I love it.

If homosexuality gets a little more exposure, little by little, transsexuality is still very much taboo in the movie/tv industry. One recent sad proof is Pretty/Handsome that was dropped by FX before it even aired... even cable networks won't touch anything that portrays transgenders as anything but mental patients! So it's nice to see there are movies out there who don't shy away from showing facets of humanity we're still too scared to look in the eye.

For every lie I unlearn I learn something new - Ani Difranco

reply