MovieChat Forums > American Idol: The Search for a Superstar (2002) Discussion > Who are your fave 3 Idol contestants eve...

Who are your fave 3 Idol contestants ever?


1- Carrie Underwood
2- Kelly Clarkson
3- David Archuleta


🐬 ma ink

reply

Carrie Underwood and Chris Daughtry.....I can't really think of another contestant that I loved as much as them.

And I could wait patiently but I really wish you would....Drop everything now

reply

All three mentioned were great and do many more.

reply

My favorite contestants are Diana DeGarmo, Carrie Underwood, Jordin Sparks, Kelly Clarkson, Tamayra Gray and Katharine McPhee

reply

In no order: Kelly Clarkson, Fantasia Barrino, and Rubin Studdard

reply

1 Carrie Underwood

2 Michael Johns

3 Adam Lambert

reply

Kelly Clarkson
Fantasia
Kimberley Locke

reply

1. Constantine Maroulis. Loved him on the show. Not so much now though :(
2. Fantasia.
3. Tie between Bucky Covington and Jason Castro because they were funny :)

reply

Melinda DoLittle
Crystal Bowersox

(there's too many ties for third place and quite a few that weren't the best singers but who I found really interesting to watch, like Naima and my cutie Dalton)

I loved the quirky Joey Cook. Found her on YouTube performing in New Orleans with Haley Reinhart. James Durbin was one I always looked forward to seeing too and Caleb. Love checking out Adam Lambert on YouTube, especially performing with Queen.

Edited to add Jessica Muesse. I just went through her performances and man did the judges really F up.

reply

No order:

Elliott Yamin
Fantasia
Bo Bice

reply

I had forgotten about Elliott until.last night. He was always great.

reply