MovieChat Forums > House of the Dead (2003) Discussion > Which do you prefer....this or Battlefie...

Which do you prefer....this or Battlefield Earth?

posted 16 years ago by bujinbudoka
6 replies | jump to latest

I could be mean and say this or Manos: Hands of Fate, but....

So if you had to line up, based on criteria, which one of these two you'd rather be faced with watching....which would it be?

I own both (a nice prank played on me by my friends, but when they come over I pop one of them in and make them watch it, usually after I've gotten hold of their car keys!) so which one would you rather have to watch?

Takers?

God Bless,

Randall

[–] lasse85 16 years ago

I just love Uwe Boll. Talk about a guy that JUST DOESN'T KNOW WHEN TO STOP

He just keeps spweing these *beep* movies. God bless him

[–] dannyboy123 16 years ago

This is like being given a choice of getting hit with pepper spray, getting shocked with a taser or getting kicked in the balls, all are terrible and will leave you in agonising pain afterwards.

[–] jamesjiao 16 years ago

This movie is so bad that the only thing worth watching is the generous number of nudity scens!!

[–] mark2115 16 years ago

I thought this movie was hilarious. The shootout with the spliced in video game footage had me rolling. I was genuinely entertained by this.

BFE was just a *beep* There were a couple of decent laughs, but it mostly just hurt my brain.

House of the Dead = 2/10 for production value, 8/10 for entertainment value
Battlefield Earth: Saga of the Year 3000 = 2.5/10 for production value, 3/10 for entertainment value

[–] AudioScienceMoxie 16 years ago

Easy. While it is akin to volunteering to get beaten up by Chuck Norris, a younger Chuck Liddell, and Fedor Emelianenko, in that order, I would have to pick this and the first The Guyver over Battlefield: Earth any day of the week. Frankly, I'd rather take a hundred kicks to the nuts than watch five minutes of this crap. Uwe Boll seriously kicks butt in the boxing ring, but his films leave you praying for a quick and merciful end. And all that said, it's STILL better than Battlefield: Earth.

[–] pumpkinescoba33 15 years ago

I would take any Uwe Boll film over Battlefield Earth. None of Boll's films have the pretension that Earth had.