MovieChat Forums > Hulk (2003) Discussion > Which movie origin do you prefer?

Which movie origin do you prefer?


Nanomeds unleashing a mutant gene created by his father or radiation resistance formula inspired by Captain America then exposing himself in a gamma chair.

reply

The exposure to Nanomeds that happened by accident, which have released what's already been put inside the Bruce by his father seems to me like a more believable origin that's also more accurate to the comics, where Bruce was a victim of abuse as a child and he was exposed to radiation by an accident.

reply

It's implied in the comics you have to have a certain gene to survive gamma exposure and become a gamma mutant, like in the TV show gamma rays from sunspots unlock hidden strengths in some humans.

reply

It's not a origin where he did it to himself like the TV show and Ultimate Marvel.

reply

Understand one of the reasons MCU not using 2003 origin because it was too complicated especially in the opening titles.

reply

In the comic origin The Hulk was inside him since the womb a damaged chromosome or a set of genes he inherited from his father due to his exposure to his atomic work.

reply

Always like the Ultimate Hulk origin more with the Hulk serum because it's more modern and it's a genetic mutation than radiation which would've caused Bruce Banner to get sick and die.

reply

I like them both

This was 616, the Incredible Hulk was ultimate mixed with the classic tv show

reply

Could do a mix of mainstream and Ultimate origins.

reply

The version from the Ang Lee movie was better, which is why the Marvel movies have basically gone with it and ignored the one from INCREDIBLE HULK.

---
"The Dig"
http://cinemarchaeologist.blogspot.com/

reply

How have they ignored the one from 2008 Hulk?

reply

By the time we get to THE AVENGERS, Hulk-outs are triggered by anger rather than, as in TIH, merely becoming excited. Banner, at the end of HULK, had come to terms with what he was, and was using his talents to help people, which is just where we find him in THE AVENGERS, like an older version of the same character. The TIH version, wherein he was fixated on the danger he posed as the Hulk and obsessed with finding a cure, is ignored. There's an exchange in THE AVENGERS in which it's asserted that the amount of radiation to which Banner was subjected "should have killed" him. This directly contradicts the TIH version, wherein he wasn't trying to kill himself and didn't subject himself to a lethal dose of radiation, but it sounds exactly like the lab accident in the '03 HULK. And it's explicitly described as an "accident" in THE AVENGERS--again, ignoring TIH, where it was an intentional experiment. It's also implied there was something special about him that allowed him to survive the radiation, which again references '03 HULK. To the proposition that he shouldn't have survived, Banner says something like, "So you're saying the other guy [the Hulk] saved me?" Implying the Hulk was something that was always inside him, just as was the case in '03 HULK.

reply

Yeah sounds like that and could've reworked the attempt to recreate Captain America's serum as a lab explosion not a rehash of TV Hulk origin, when Coulson explains it to Captain America there's no mention of Banner experimenting on himself.

reply

It's also implied there was something special about him that allowed him to survive the radiation, which again references '03 HULK. To the proposition that he shouldn't have survived, Banner says something like, "So you're saying the other guy [the Hulk] saved me?" Implying the Hulk was something that was always inside him, just as was the case in '03 HULK.


Hulk was probably a damage chromosome or a set of genes created by the Celestials.

reply

Think it's due to the fallout with Edward Norton and the rewrites he made?

reply

No, I just think everyone involved realized the '03 HULK was just way better. TIH has been basically ignored; nothing it established was followed up on.

reply

Since Norton left bits of TIH were ignored. 03 Hulk was more comic accurate than any of the live action versions were he was exposed to radiation by accident when trying to save somebody and with the modern belief that The Hulk was a damaged chromosome or super soldier serum gene.

reply

The father one.

It seems pretty obvious a lot of he's pent up frustration comes from his hatred to his father and that story line is more relateable and interesting.

reply