MovieChat Forums > We Were Soldiers (2002) Discussion > Worst scene, always ruins it for me

Worst scene, always ruins it for me


I've scene this movie three times and I've read the book. Despite the differences between the book and the movie (that's always a given) and other problems with the film, I like it. It's entertaining and gives the viewer an idea of how desperate things can get for soldiers under fire.

However, there is one scene that always stands out as being just terrible and breaks the spell of the movie for me. It occurs just after the photographer, played by Barry Pepper, has fought and then returns to his camera in order to document the fight. What follows is a series of black and white images of the battle that would have been very effective on their own. Instead, we are shown color scenes of the photographer superimposed on the b&w photos, while he is taking photos or reacting to what is going on around him. It feels like an after thought that was added after the principal shooting was complete. I have always felt that scene to be tacky and very out of sync with the rest of the film.

Anybody else bothered by this scene? Or perhaps some of you especially enjoyed that scene. Thoughts?

reply

Seen this movie not scene this movie.

reply


Nope. Not me. I loved this film.


😎

reply

I just caught this on cable recently. I agree, it was a great film. The scenes of the wives delivering those dreaded letters to their friends were heartbreaking. As tough as it must be to be in combat, I cannot imagine living as they must have lived -- in absolute terror every time someone knocked on the door.

reply


My favorite scene is the last one where they come charging over the hill, and then the helicopter gunships cut the enemy to pieces! It was so cool, I actually stood and cheered when I first saw it. BTW, I'm a proud Army Veteran.


😎

reply

Yes!

I just saw that scene and I hated it

reply