MovieChat Forums > Shallow Hal (2001) Discussion > I love this movie, but I have a question...

I love this movie, but I have a question....

posted 9 years ago by noirgirl
2 replies | jump to latest

The miserable Nurse Tanya is seen by Hal as an old skinny hag. Then in real life, Rosemary is talking to her in the car, and Tanya is revealed as a pretty girl who is after the man with the spina bifida because he just sold his company and is now rich. But there was no resolution to that. Anyone know or think what actually happened? Did he get taken after all or did he wise up? Thanks!

[–] randysw12 9 years ago

She had no resolution. She was used as an example. Hal seen everybody's inner personality and seen her for what she really is. She may look pretty on the outside, but he seen her for what she really was. Same with how he saw Rosemary. It was the complete opposite.

[–] sage2112 9 years ago

^^ this