I've just finished a full watch through of Enterprise and... I've found it a real mixed bag. On the one hand, I think it's been far less "Oh, look how perfect we all are" than the other series, which I've liked. The technology has been less perfect, there's more of a sense of exploration and finding things out for the first time, and more sense of risk and danger.
Having said that, even when the stories have interesting elements that are better than the preceding Trek series, they haven't always been executed very well.
I also found the characters a bit mediocre. It's odd to watch 4 seasons of something, and still feel like the characters haven't really been defined. Maybe Archer and Phlox somewhat. The rest, despite episodes that 'expand' on them, still don't leave you with a real grasp of their characters. Maybe T'Pol, though she's the centre of so much but also one of the least interesting characters (and unfortunately, no offence to Blalock, I just don't find her a particularly great actress. She was clearly supposed to be Enterprise's 7of9, but Jerri Ryan is a big part of what makes that role. She brings character to it even when the scripts are lacking).
I guess the best way to put it, is that if you grab any well written and defined character from any series or film or book, then drop them in a different situation, your imagination should still be able to predict how that character would react. With most of the crew of Enterprise, apart from the general "we usually try to do the right thing" there's never any feeling of that. Not that I found, anyway. That's where Next Gen and even Voyager succeed, despite often having weaker stories than Enterprise.
And that last episode... yikes. What's really bad about it, is that it isn't even that bad. It's just a bit of a pathetic whimper to go out on. If most of that episode had been earlier in the season as a stand-alone throwaway it would've been more fun.
reply
share