MovieChat Forums > Bully (2001) Discussion > Hitman's Dad saying 'tell her you'll wri...

Hitman's Dad saying 'tell her you'll write to her'


Anyone else think this is a weird scene? Lisa calls the hitman's house, gets his brother, tells the brother that they committed a murder, and the brother relays the information to their father--the information that his son killed someone--and the father wants the kid to get off the phone and says "tell her you'll write to her," clearly indicating she's going to be in trouble. But if she's going to be in trouble, his son is too! All he does is hang up the phone and take another sip of his whiskey?!?!?!

reply

in the book he's the father of a guy that lent them the baseball bat for the murder.
that scene makes no sense does it?

___________________
uh huh dot com

reply

That's right! I remember now. But the way they changed it for the movie makes no sense at all, and is actually pretty confusing. It always irked me.

reply

lol@hang up & take another sip of whiskey

___________________
uh huh dot com

reply

to me that whole scene just underlined how stupid they all were, they did not have a freakin clue and were just BEGGING to get caught. How could Lisa have not of thought of the consequences beforehand?? How could they not have had a proper plan to get away with it?? and now she's just talking about it with one of their brothers, his father...who else wants to get on the phone?!? The old dude saying ''tell her you'll write'', he was probably just as flabbergasted as I am at their naivety and stupidity

reply


My take away from that scene is that murder wasn’t a big deal for the guy. Obviously at least in the film the family had a hard way of living. That was the point of the hit man being there. Even if he was inept enough to even put himself in that group of people (that’s where your real complaint should be), he was comfortable with the idea of handling that level of violence. Had they followed his plan, kept cool, they probably would have gotten away with it.

It seemed like the girl wanted the hit man’s father to take care of her. What was he supposed to do? I’m sure his idea was either to try and alibi his son or let his son face the music. What he wouldn’t want to do is implicate himself for her.

It has been a while since I saw the movie and i wish I could remember it better so I could more confidently explain how it wasn’t a logic gap.

Of all the families that was the one that seemed most tightly knit and together, oddly. I think they were maybe just already gang affiliated in some way.

Also...comparing the film to what really happened is a no win situation. I suspect Larry Clark (who played the hitman’s dad) would say he was going to a higher emotional truth than be slave to facts. The kids seem to deny most of what they’re accused of anyway. I read a message board a long while back that had one of them on there a couple years after she got out of jail, talking about the movie. She basically denied everything in it. She was a born again Christian.

i do think the movie’s answers were a little stock about absent parents, etc. I don’t think there really is much of any explanation for what happened. Kids are always emotional and about individuality but really they would never want to be seen as individual from the pack. Add some genuine wrong done against some of them, too many drugs or drinks, and suddenly there’s a bad mix of group think and inertia. But who really knows? Probably least of all the kids themselves.

reply

[deleted]

He knows his son's in trouble but there's nothing he can do about it. He's certainly not going to stick his neck out for this crazy bimbo if his son's already going down and she was the one who got the son into it in the first place.

The 'tell her you'll write' cracked me up, even if the scene was so grim, and it amounted to the father telling her to f___ off.

When darkness overcomes the heart, Lil' Slugger appears...

reply

The 'tell her you'll write' cracked me up, even if the scene was so grim, and it amounted to the father telling her to f___ off.


But that's my point: it also amounted to the father telling his son that he can piss off too . . . and he didn't seem the least bit concerned about it. He just takes another sip of his whiskey. For God's sake, the hitman lived in the same house and he didn't even call him over to ask him what the hell was going on!

reply