MovieChat Forums > Malèna (2001) Discussion > the hair cutting-humiliation scene

the hair cutting-humiliation scene


Cutting the hair of women who were accused of collaboration happened extensively towards the end of WWII, particularly in France but also in Italy, Belgium, Holland. More recently it was used as a punishment in such places as Ireland during The Troubles.

I am wondering what social or psychological forces lie behind this. It's obviously a lynch mob mentality at work, but (as a gay man) I wonder why is cutting a woman's hair considered so humiliating? Is it symbolic in some way?

reply

I think it's because a lot of women like their hair.

reply

hair is a sign of fertility and womanhood. to shear hair is to unsex the woman.

I think Netherland's Zwartboek (Blackbook) did it better with the hair shaving

reply

good answer

reply

It is indeed symbolic. There is an old belief that the soul resides in the hair. For example, when a woman decides to become a nun and enter a convent, her hair is cut as a sign that she is giving up part of herself, her individuality, to become someone who will only serve her god henceforth.

In the middle ages, when a woman was accused of being a witch by the inquisition, one of the first actions was that her head was shorn. It was a violation of her person, of her womanhood. In the German language, there is a saying to this day which goes "to get away unshorn" - meaning, to get away unharmed/intact.

In magical traditions, hair is often used as a substitute for the person. And throughout history, people have kept locks of hair of their beloved, or of a son or daughter, as a keepsake. Hair is a deeply personal substance.

reply

If you cut out the hair of a prostitute and leave her looking horrible like in the movie, it's obvious that men will feel repulsion and clients won't approach her the same.
Even if she's not a prostitute, on a simple mob level, cutting the hair of a woman (like butcher it) makes her undesirable, makes her less of a woman, less than a human being.
That's the stereotype association: long hair=femininity.

reply

They wanted to intimidate her, make her ashamed. She had beautiful hair and they wanted to intimidate her, and they did.

reply