MovieChat Forums > The Patriot (2000) Discussion > The Brits Have a Right to be Upset

The Brits Have a Right to be Upset


I looked up and down the postings for this movie and I haven't found an important point stated. It's in regard to the scene where the British soldiers rounded up the inhabitants of the village, put them in the church, and burned them to death.

THIS IS SOMETHING THE NAZIS DID TO A VILLAGE IN FRANCE IN 1944!! Unless an incident like this actually happened during the Revolutionary War (which I highly doubt), the Brits have a right to be outraged by this movie.

reply

I'm American, and even American historians admit this movie is highly historically inaccurate. So your not entirely wrong to be upset. Personally, I think this movie's purpose is to make Americans feel a warm, patriotic sensation inside when they watch it, not necessarily to tell the history of the war accurately.

reply

First and foremost, it's a movie. A work of fiction.

It's comical that overly-sensitive modern day Brits can get so butthurt over being portrayed as imperial tyrants in period films. When in fact for a great part of English history, that's exactly what they were. Accept it, in a great many stories from history, when told from the perspective of the opposition, the British are the villains. Period. When the story of the American revolution is told from the American perspective, the British are the villains. It's called "perspective", get some.

reply

Americans have a right to be upset over how badly this movie was made. It was basically Braveheart with 18th century guns, and just about as inaccurate.

reply

"It was basically Braveheart with 18th century guns, and just about as inaccurate."

You say that like it's a bad thing???

reply

I got bored and left the room while my dad and brother were watching. The entire movie was just another ego trip for Mel Gibson.

reply

For me it was a beautiful look into colonial America. Two weeks ago I visited the home of the craftsmen who built the guns, tomahawks, knives, hunting pouches for Gibson.

reply

Wow, this post is filled with hostile whiny little bitches, Brits and Americans. Honestly, insulting people based on their nationality is rather pathetic.

reply

I would never have accepted this movie as being a doc on the Rev War. In Star Wars we have Good Guys v Bad Guys, in The Patriot, we have the same. Whether this actually happened doesn't matter. It's just a fanciful story.

reply