Carvel?


James tells Tripp in the novel that his hometown is Carvel--pronounced, I assume, the way Mickey Rooney and the rest of the Hardys pronounced it in all those movies, i.e. "CAR-vul". When the subject comes up in the movie, the town is pronounced "car-VELL". Didn't anyone pick up on the Andy Hardy reference, knowing that James is the ultimate master of movie trivia? Or didn't the screenwriter or director remember the franchise that made MGM so much money in the '30's and '40's? I love both the novel and the movie, but it's always puzzled me that this particular old-movie reference seems to have gone right over the heads of everybody involved (I'm sure Michael Chabon put it in to refer to the Andy Hardy movies, though he never spells it out in the book).

reply

That might be the case although that's a very extrapolated deduction. Very impressive if it were the source of the reference. Chabon definitely appreciates detail.

Carvel ice cream is very popular on the east coast and is pronounced "Car-vell". That pronunciation just reminds me of that and helps build the east coast vibe imo.

reply

Carvel ice cream is very popular on the east coast and is pronounced "Car-vell". That pronunciation just reminds me of that and helps build the east coast vibe imo.

I can't help it; I know it's coming, but that part always throws me back to the thrill of a child on occasional visits to the local ice cream shop.
HOWEVER, Chabon is indeed known for detail and I highly doubt the ice cream reference was intentional. Particularly since Pittsburgh is definitely not "east coast"...

reply

Read the trivia page.

reply