MovieChat Forums > O (2001) Discussion > Hugo gets off the hook??

Hugo gets off the hook??


During the last voice over from Hugo as he drives away in the police car he says he always wanted to live like a hawk and that he will fly someday. I took this as he will beat the court system and get away with everything. Think about it, there were no witnesses to anything that he did. He could say Roger hit Michael in the head with the crowbar which made him shoot Roger. Odin killed Desi and then he could say that Odin shot Emily because there were no witnesses and Odin had the gun in the end of the film after he shot himself. Even though that girl drove up and saw Hugo on the road with Michael and Roger on the ground, she still didn't witness what happened. Does anyone else agree with me that Hugo would eventually get out of this and that is what he meant by saying one day he will fly??

reply

bump

reply

no, thats not what he meant.
he means kind of stand ou from the crowd

reply

Well, since this is just a modern day version of Othello, and Hugo is supposed to be the character Iago, if they go based on the actual story, Iago/Hugo is arrested. They never say if he was executded or not, although it does say that he is to be punished severely. But who knows, Michael Cassio (same name in play and movie) didn't die in the play, but he did in O, so there really is no saying what they meant by his monologue at the end.




Friends Don't Let Friends Watch New ABC Shows!
RIP Traveler

reply

Micheal DID NOT DIE!

He was shot in the leg and he was just unconcious

reply

Oh, my bad.




House: Hey Wilson! I'm gonna cut some cripple's eye out. Wanna come watch?
Wilson: Good times.

reply

Thats okay!

reply

You can die from being shot in the leg. There are arteries there, you know.

Let us drink, gentlemen, till we roll under the table in vomit and oblivion!

reply

Actually...they never mentioned if he lived. come to think of it. He lost a lot of blood. not only was he shot in the leg, but Hugo also whacked him with a crowbar in the back of his head. Micheal was already losing a lot of blood even before Hugo shot Roger. The bodies were found only after Brandy comes running back to the dorm, which has to be at the very least about 30 mins. That's enough to kill any person.

"hahahahahaha hehe hoho he ho he haha he ha ho!!! And I thought My jokes were bad"
-The JOKER

reply

He was shot in the leg and he was just unconcious

The paramedics were applying pressure to his leg at the end. clearly he lived.

reply

Hmmm. That's actually an interesting question. I always just assumed that he ended up in jail, since it's pretty strongly implied that Iago is executed in Othello. However, in Othello there were a lot more witnesses; I don't remember the details, but by the end Gratiano, Montano, Lodovico, and Cassio all know what happened. Technically Hugo has no witnesses except Brandy.

However, I'm pretty sure that whoever posted above me is right. He just means that people will notice him. And they already have, really; that is the one good point (to him) about being exposed.

reply

After Hugo shot the girl in the bedroom he ran out carrying the gun and got tackled by a guy who kicked the gun away. That guy is a witness. And I took his last voice over to mean that he will not have attention and stand out from the crowd.

reply

Man, I was wondering how it ended. I tuned in a little late on a satellite channel. It was the first time I've seen it. Wouldn't you know that the satellite cut out, searching for a signal for several minutes, just long enough to show the end where the coach is notified, he uncovers the corpse on the gurney (who was that?) and Hugo drives away in the black and white. What a lousy time for the satellite to go out! Now I'm going to have to rent it to fill in the gaps.

The sex scene was very disturbing, but overall I thought the movie was engrossing and left me wondering why it has taken me 7 years to see it.

reply

In Othello, Iago kills Emilia right in front of Othello, Cassio, Montano, and Lodovico. But who saw Hugo kill Emily in this one? Odin, who promptly proceeded to commit suicide not two minutes later. I'd say Hugo got off scott free here.

reply

Nah! He was there when Michael got shot, when Desi and Emily were killed, and they would tie him to these crimes. So, he would do some serious jail time for conspiracy and murder.

reply











i rewatched that scene where the girl was saying hugo u begged me to steal that scarf and he shot her.i thought the other teammate and odin and brandi were in the room,but in fact its just hugo and odin and the two dead girls.the other two walked out after the arguing started and after seeing the dead girl desi.so actually odin was the only witness.but heres the rub.hyow did brandi know hugo killed mike and roger,when she arrived to see hugo approach the car saying call 911 and mike and roger were already down?she didnt see anything,yet she flew back to the dorm saying omg mike is dead and roger,and those guys say what happenned and she says hugo killed em.well she didnt see that.what everyone did see was hugo walk in with the gun he got from the scene where he shot roger and roger shot mike,and also hugo clubbed mike.but hugo wasnt seen with the gun in the dorm till he pulled it and shot his whore.so even brandi didnt see him do that either.nor the other teammate.only odin did.then i will say the other teammate did see him walk out with it and shoved him over and kicked it away,but even then he only heard a shot and saw him holding it shortly after,didnt witness him shoot anyone.and all of it was cancelled out due to odin picking the gun up distraught and ranting breaking down then committing suicide.but it does make sense based on brandi seeing hugo on the road with 2 bodies,then hearing the argument about hugo and the scarf,mixed with the shot,him leaving the room with the gun,and the other kid seeing him holding it,all that could clear odin who is dead anyways,but it makes it logical that hugo be arrested since he was the centerpiece of every body and death at the end.







spectre can

suck it.

reply

We are to assume he didn't get away with it since he was arrested. It's not like Law and Order where they are going to show the prosecutor's part and everything. I know in the original he didn't get away with it so it's safe to assume he doesn't in this as well.

Cassie is going to see Taylor Swift live in Chicago on October 10th 2009!!

reply

You also have to remember that he walked out of the room with the gun, and since it's modern, and you want to get technical, there are forensics as well. His hand prints were all over the gun, and the crowbar that was used to hit Mike was in Hugo's car. No gun at Roger's and Michael's crime scene and matching bullet calibers points all towards Hugo. To prove it was Hugo's gun, they could trace back to the pawn shop if the gun was rightfully attained.


But that's looking at it REALLY technically, I just think he doesn't get away and lives a dream that he's some unique guy in his head in prison

reply

I completely agree with CKYMaX. I don't think Hugo got at all away with anything in the end for Technical and witness reasons. O had the gun and killed Desi, but everyone witnessed everything he said before he killed himself. He said Hugo manipulated him and I think it further supports the evidence of the crime scenes. I have no sympathy at all for Hugo. I think what he said at the end meant that he always wanted to be loved and in the spot light, but now that he has it, it was sparked on by his jealousy and all that he had done. I think it was symbolic that everyone watched him get taken to the police car and heard what he had done, then you see his father get told something had happened about his son and O at the game.

reply

I reckon so. But let's consider how manipulative Hugo is and apply it to a court setting. For hitting Michael with the crowbar, he could have been just swinging in the midst of things trying to get them to stop fighting. He took the gun and the crowbar in a stressful bout of confusion; I mean, why did Jackie Kennedy climb onto the back of the limo and pick up the bit of JFK's skull? Under such circumstances, it's only logical that one would not be thinking rationally. Then Odin killed Emily, Hugo forced the gun from him and went stumbling down the hall.

Yes, in Othello the character Iago, one assumes, was executed. But this is updated for not only a modern setting but a modern high school setting. The modern courts are different and a teenager would be looked at differently. A person is innocent until proven guilty, and it begs to reason that Hugo could weasel his way out of convicting evidence.

But then there's the debate about whether or not Mike survived. There are arteries in the legs, so it's possible that the bullet could have hit and he bled out. If he survived, though, then that changes everything about the ensuing court case. But even then it would be boiled down to Michael's word vs. Hugo's, and let's not forget Hugo's manipulation factor, and the fact that Hugo wouldn't be the type to choke when he finally gets the attention he's craving.

In the end I think the evidence a jury would be presented with would be circumstantial. Maybe they would get Hugo with something, probably some drug/alcohol/firearm possession charges, but in the end I don't think Hugo would be sent to the same fate as Iago, meaning execution or extreme sentencing.

But maybe I'm just over-analyzing.

On the run from Johnny Law...Ain't no trip to Cleveland.

reply


Depends if Michael lives or not.

We see a stretcher being put into an ambulance at the scene, and the paramedics dont seem to be rushing around it like they would if the person was alive. So the implication is that Michael was dead. (It definitely wasnt Roger, because he was still on the ground; and I aint talking about the separate scene were a clearly dead Desi is put into the ambulance and her father is on hand).

If Michael is dead, then there is only circumstantial evidence against Hugo. But it is quite strong circumstantial evidence.

He has prints on 2 murder weapons (the crowbar and the gun). (Which doesnt prove he was the killer. He can explain this easily).

He will have powder burns etc showing that he fired the gun, plus Roger's blood splatter. (He will have to admit killing Roger, and claim self defence. He can deny killing Emily.)

He got the gun from the pawnbroker. (If the pawnbroker can be found, then Hugo is screwed. But the pawnbroker might not be traced.)

It might be possible to tie the glass in Desi's room to Hugo. (But so what. In itself, that proves nothing whatsoever).


With a good lawyer, he should walk.


reply

I was thinking the same thing- not in relation to the monolouge but that based on character assessment Hugo was to slick and would get himself off the hook.

reply

For any prosecution lawyer, this would be incredibly easy to convict him.
1)Yes he shoots Emily, he comes out of the room with the gun!! the other guy tackles him, and then Odin picks the gun up after that..So the police will find that Hugo did, in fact, shoot Emily.

Plus, Michael could still be alive..

ALSO, he TAKES the weapons from the previous crime...why would any innocent bystander take the gun? This would definitely link him to the other crime. They will find the crowbar as well as the thing that Emily stole for Hugo in Hugo's possession(it's in his car) ! When they find that shirt thing, they will use that for conspiracy and murder.

As far as what he said at the end, I wasn't paying close attention to it, sorry I can't help about that.

reply

I don't think that's how his little speech was meant to be interpreted. It meant that all his life he's wanted to stand out. During the movie notice that Hugo is not popular, nor is he unpopular, he's somewhere in the middle, he's mediocre. His grades are good but nothing to get excited about, his father doesn't pay much attention to him, especially since he's just okay at basketball. Throughout the movie you can tell how much he wants his father's attention, which is why he plotted Odin's demise. Odin was who he wanted to be, Odin was the one could "soar above everything and everyone." In his speech he compares Odin to the hawk, and he describes the hawk as "proud, powerful, determined, dark." He also says "Even though all the other birds probably wanna be hawks, they hate him for what they can't be." Basically his end speech was just him finally saying how he felt about Odin and explained why he did what he did. As far as him getting away with everything, I don't think he could have beat the system. He's obviously smart, but not that smart, and due to his personality, I think there's a part of him that would tell all, as his plan was quite genius and he will gain some recognition and finally stand out, which is what he's always wanted. Furthermore, he did shoot Emily but that doesn't mean that she died, she could have survived that shot, and people could have heard Emily, Hugo, and Odin's conversation that they had in the room, plus Odin's speech before he died will definitely put suspicion on Hugo. And lastly, Michael did not die.

reply

The thing is... I don't think Hugo WANTS to get away with it. I think he wants to show the world how clever he is and how he manipulated everyone. Some people think prison is a price worth paying just to get the attention they want.

reply

Oh that speech from Hugo at the end about flying...I just wanted him to shut the he%$ up!

reply