MovieChat Forums > Gladiator (2000) Discussion > Why didn't Maximus just go back to his m...

Why didn't Maximus just go back to his military?


The execution attempt was made by the Ceasar's men, not Maximus men.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

Maximus knew that Commodus had already sent a contingent of his men to murder his family, as told to him by Quintus. On top of that they also had a several hour head start. Whether the right decision or not in a tense situation, he didn't want to waste time in trying to get to his family first in order to save them. He would probably figure he'd be able to move faster individually then a larger group would, after Quintus' betrayal he was having some trust issues, and most importantly to top it all off him having to sway his men back against their new emperor and his group of soldiers who are still in the same area/encampment who would fight to stop him would have taken up even more time. (Given what Maximus says later it is possible that he could have succeeded at that, but time would have to be sept on debate and probably battle, and even defeating Commodus there wouldn't do anything about the guys already on the move to his farm in Spain.) Or at least that's how I see it.

reply

Maximus knew that Commodus had already sent a contingent of his men to murder his family, as told to him by Quintus.


I thought it was the Praetorians...so then his men betrayed him. Despite Marcus Aurelius confirming it was Maximus who controlled them. And again at the end, he was counting on them despite not seeing them for years, it doesn't coincide.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

I was referring to the Praetorians. Look at the uniforms of he guys who ride into Maximus' estate. It's that of Commodus' guard.

reply

When you said "his men", I thought you meant Maximus' men, not Commodus.

Then the question remains, why not secure his military? He would have saved Rome, and it could be argued his family as well, since more men could carry more supplies. If not, they would be swiftly avenged, plus the true kings wishes would be carried out immediately.

It could be argued that Quintus betrayal (later explained with "I'm a soldier, I obey") was what was out of character, given how Maximus men are stated as being so loyal, by everyone, and are shown as such at the end...even Quintis.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

Saving Rome would have been the last thing on his mind. He knew men had been dispatched to murder his FAMILY and he was desperately trying to get there fast enough to save them.

reply

Then the question remains, why not secure his military? He would have saved Rome, and it could be argued his family as well, since more men could carry more supplies. If not, they would be swiftly avenged, plus the true kings wishes would be carried out immediately.



http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

I just said he had to get to his family as fast as possible. That means he didn't have time to try to gather his men.

reply

I just said his men could have helped get him there faster, going by himself was an absolute failure.


http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

Who knows how long it would have taken to muster the men and what opposition he would have faced once he revealed himself to be alive? He had zero time to waste.

reply

The time he wasted going slowly alone got his family killed, seems obvious to anyone it's faster going with men to support you.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

The time he wasted going slowly alone got his family killed, seems obvious to anyone it's faster going with men to support you.

Then why do message riders, spies and scouts always ride alone?

He was a father and a husband first and foremost. He was a general second.




"I can't help but notice that there are skulls all over everything. Are we the baddies?"

reply

Then why do message riders, spies and scouts always ride alone?


Only if the distance is short enough where one ride is a advantage.

Nothing to do with the distance Maximus had to cover, so lengthy that the time he wasted going slowly alone got his family killed.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

Only if the distance is short enough where one ride is a advantage.


He took more than one horse so he could swap along the way. I don't know how this could be made any more clear for you.


"I can't help but notice that there are skulls all over everything. Are we the baddies?"

reply

He and his horse were exhausted, weak, and pathetically slow. Did you see the movie?

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

Your posts make no sense regarding traveling alone. Generally speaking a group is not faster than an individual. I don't even know how you're arguing that point.

As for why he didn't secure the military first, he was thinking emotionally not militarily. It's highly unlikely that a small group of soldiers would've trampled his son in front of what would have had to have been more than 20-30 workers (for a farm that size), and lived to tell about it much less rape his wife numerous times. That's the problem I had with that part of the movie. As slaves or workers of a seemingly upstanding guy and elite soldier, they would've been trained for attacks on the farm. Yet we are only shown 2 people in a field.

reply

Its hinted that Maximus have lost controll of his men after the original Ceaser's death. Phoenix-Ceaser asks Maximus if he will serve him, to wich Maximus responds by just leaving the tent. The new Ceaser was well aware that Maximus was very loyal to his father, and seemed unsure to how Maximus would react to the death of his father.

After Maximus exits Ceaser's tent and enters his own, he confronts a soldier asking him why he is STILL in arms, indicating that the soldier most likely served under Maximus command in the opening battle at least.

In short, he couldnt go back to his men because he lost command of them.



"I told the others, they didn't believe me. You're all doomed. You're all doomed."

reply

Maximus exits Ceaser's tent and enters his own, he confronts a soldier asking him why he is STILL in arms, indicating that the soldier most likely served under Maximus command in the opening battle at least.


A fair point, but at least some of men were loyal later on, indicating that they would have been loyal from the start.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

Maximus was just betrayed by a soldier under his command. He had no idea of who he could trust at this point, at least not any of his men. It isent untill he encounters one of his men in Rome he realizes he has a group of loyal soldiers waiting for him.


"I told the others, they didn't believe me. You're all doomed. You're all doomed."

reply

The guy with the scar-face you mean. Well you've answered the question about why didn't Maximus go back to his military.

Now the only question is does it make sense that his men would betray him.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

They were technically not HIS men, but Romes. So their commander in chief would always be whomever was Ceaser. Maximus was just leading the troops in his name.



"I told the others, they didn't believe me. You're all doomed. You're all doomed."

reply

Technically yes, but even Marcus Aurelius said the men follow Maximus over everyone. Which was later confirmed to be true.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

Hmm no Quintus was not under Maximus' command (even though his rank may be higher).

reply

The execution attempt was made by the Ceasar's men, not Maximus men.


Hollywood. In real life a man like Maximus going to his troops and usurping an Emperor was a huge problem. There's no way Commodus would have treated a popular general like that in the middle of his army.

reply

[deleted]