Black and White Segments.
Why does the film switch between color and black and white?
shareJust the director's way of filming the scenes. We tend to think of most events from the early '60s as B&W, because that was the prevalent film choice. So, it sort of has a documentary/news piece feel to it... as if "You were there." Very nice transitions to color from B&W, btw. Very seamless.
shareI didn't like the switching back and forth. I think that the washout color of Saving Private Ryan, not the color shown on TV, the color used in the theater. Another method Spelberg used was in Shindler's List, he chose to use black and white because he felt the movie would be so full of blood, most people would have had trouble setting through it. Poinantly the only color thing he showed was the little girl's red coat running through the ghetto as it is being liquidated.
Being I was born after Kennedy's death, the film I identify with him with most was the Abraham Zapruder film, in color. I think it would have been better if the black and white scenes would have been restricted to news footage.
Antother film that switches this way is called Task Force(1949), it is black and white for most of the film but turns to color fur the final 18 minutes of the final battle scene and until the movie ends. It is one of those old movies that the never show then TCM gets it and shows if for about a year and then puts up for another 10 years. Good watch though, if you like history and aviation.
I didn't get the switching. I thought there might be a running motif but I don't think so from one viewing.
Billy Wilder Page, Play the Movie Smiley Game
www.screenwritingdialogue.com
I agree. The whole movie should have been in color. The switching didn't make it feel more realistic. The acting was engrossing enough.
Frank: Just a man.
Harmonica: An ancient race.
I could have understood the B&W thing if it was trying to show certain events as they would have been witnessed by the public at the time (ie on B&W TV) but the B&W segments seemed to be completely random.
I can't really add much to what's already been said. But I am relieved that it is apparently not the case that I am just not bright enough to see the theme.
I think it would have been neat, as suggested above, to show famous, historical images in black and white. Otherwise, the randomness of the black-and-white segments is my only complaint against Thirteen Days.
please insert signature hereshare
In his commentary, director Roger Donaldson says he was trying to convey a Life Magazine feel to certain segments (I wouldn't even call them scenes because they were so brief) in order to provide a sense of history, as if you were reading about the Kennedys in the press at the time.
I don't think he was successful, though. The whole film is supposed to be a "you are there" immersion into that particular time in history. These B & W interludes didn't seem any more historical or evocative of the era than any of the other scenes. The switches just seemed artificial; they take the viewer out of the immediacy of the story and make the viewer aware that he/she is watching a movie.
Having lived through the Crisis in a state of childhood angst,
watching the B&W sequences brought back that "shocky" sense
of dread and depression that I recall from half-suppressed
fear of nuclear war reinforced every week at school by drills
through the late 50's & early '60's.
I could literally feel the serotonin drain away watching the
fades to B&W.
It was an artistic choice by the director, to convey some additional feelings that he felt leaving it one or the other didn't do. In my opinion, it was a POOR artistic choice, and damaged the film.
share