MovieChat Forums > The Sopranos (1999) Discussion > Did Noah Have Sex With Caitlin?

Did Noah Have Sex With Caitlin?


We know that Noah and Caitlin studied together and then Noah abruptly ended things with Meadow not long after....

What do you think?

reply

Sopranos is a work of fiction. Nothing was filmed onscreen or even suggested that they ever hooked up

reply

No way. Noah reluctantly let Caitlin into his room to study, was pissed that he got a bad grade because of her and that she found fault with his notes from a previous semester. If Noah found fault with Meadow, Caitlin was exponentially worse.

reply

I think they did. Noah was reluctant to let her in, but he did, and as soon as she sat down, she started giving him the eye. If he gave in and took the easy lay, it would explain why he wasn't as focused on studying as much as he needed to be. And Noah was the kind of guy who would blame a girl for his bad grade, even though he was more than willing to nail her.

Notice afterwards that Caitlin's disposition about college life immediately improved. And maybe Noah decided to dump Meadow so abruptly afterwards due to the guilt of it, on top of her immaturity and racist family.

reply

You do know the Sopranos is fiction, right. So show me the scene or tell me where it was implied they had sex?

reply

Caitlin was too bat shit crazy and Noah was too smart to fall for that.

reply

I wouldn't say she was "bat shit crazy", she was just adjusting to the city. It's quite a transition for a young woman to move to NYC.

reply