Would I like She-Ra?


Hi, I'm a potential She-Ra fan, and I'd like to know if you think I'd like this show.

I've seen about 12 episodes of He-Man and thought they were good.
I saw "Secret of the Sword" and two more episodes and they were okay. SOTS I liked. One episode was good and the other one... I didn't care for.

What I wanted to know was: Is this show pretty girly and magical? Are there guys in this shows as well as girls? What's the deal with Madame Razz being a witch and is she like the same kind of magician as Orko?

I'm thinking He-Man might be more along my lines, but I don't know. Any help would be good!

I've finally gone daffy.

reply

Hmm...was She-Ra 'girly'...

I was very much a tomboy growing up. I didn't care for dresses and dolls and all that girly stuff.

But I was totally into She-Ra, because while I wasn't a girly-girl, I still liked to have a girl who could be the hero and really kick butt doing it. She-Ra wasn't a shrinking violet. She and tough and feminine without being 'butch' (sorry if that phrase offends anyone) and 'girly'.

The Rebellion had regular male support in the character of Bow, and Adam/He-man would make the odd appearance. Also, there was another character named Sea Hawk who made a couple showings.

As for Madame Razz, she's a little like Orko... She's a very (very) old enchantress whose spells are more likely to go wrong than right; so she's more like Orko in that respect. She is usually the comic relief in the episode.

Hordak, leader of the Horde presence on Etheria was a much more cruel, evil, menacing villain than Skeletor.

I never thought about it much as a child, but She-Ra's battle was much more serious than the little tiffs He-Man would have against Skeletor and his minions. He-Man's world was relatively peaceful. The 'good guys' ruled. It was a different story for She-Ra's Etheria. They were at war against an oppressive, occupying force. While censors made it impossible to be truly 'graphic' in its depictions of war, the reality of it is that both the Horde and the Rebellion could have suffered major loses in their weekly match-ups. Violence, especially on a cartoon more geared towards girls, of course, wouldn't have been acceptable in the 80s.

So while we were not shown the casualties of war, I do think She-Ra is worth a look!

reply

Thanks!

I've finally gone daffy.

reply

[deleted]

Very good post, but I have to disagree with you about Orko. In truth, Orko was an extremely powerful and accomplished magician, but first he lost his wand which helpped him focus his magic, and second he was on an "alien" planet which messed up his magic severely.

A good showing of how clever Orko is, is an episode where Beastman and Trap Jaw capture him. They keep forcing him to use his magic for them, but he seems to use the "twist" that Eternia does to his spells to his advantage. Think two villains that get a genie that keeps twisting their words and wishes around...you would have this episode. :)

reply

She-ra is a sweetheart. Go for it!

reply

[deleted]

I always liked this show when I was little. It came on around when I was 4 (1985). I'm going to get a few episodes next time I hit Best Buy.




"'07 Bonnie & Clyde, me and my neice"-J_Malice

reply

This show isn't 'girly' if this is what you're concerned about.

First off Adora, the mortal version of She-ra was kidnapped as a baby from Eternia. She has to atone for having worked (under a spell) with the Horde and abused people. for several years. Pretty heavy stuff. She had been the Horde force captain!!

Her horse Spirit, unlike Cringer is not afraid either. it (unsure of gender) likes adventures and ideas.

You might like this show better than He-man

reply

Yeah, it wasn't shojo. It was a shallow attempt to market to girls by making the main character female & spicing up the color palate. I think they wanted to make it more girly. They just didn't know how to do that. End result was a more polished, fleshed-out version of He-Man.

reply

I think it had more depth than He-man. Even as kid Cringer whining got on me. Sprit never whines and can always take care of themselves.

Adora is on her own in another dimension, unlike Adam she does not live with her parents--. She has friends yes but essentially she has to be able to take care of herself. They don't care that she was born a princess. On Etheria, the royalty are Angelina and Glimmer.

Adora meets her birth parents on Eternia (where presumably she could have liven a far easier life of leisure) but tells them she must return to Etheria to work for it's freedom. She-ra is biologically a 'princess' but she fights for another planet's liberation at the expense of not seeing her family.

Even brainwashed Adora who we first meet is a stronger character than Adam. She received training in leadership, management, fighting, planning (among many other skills) even if obviously misusing them at first. When Shaow weaver's mind control spell is broken, Adora is still self-confident, self assertive and organized.

Although his royal parents are 'good' people, Adam is constantly verbally abused by others because he is clumsy....etc. They never show him skills which will not make him clumsy and just keep picking on him. I disliked that when I was little. Adora is not 'clumsy' ...etc

reply

[deleted]

The only thing that ticked me off about the toys was the crystal castle toy looked nothing like the cartoon. Okay this was bc of manufacturing limitations but I did not know this as a kid.

I suspect that w our more flexible ideas of gender...etc today it would do well as everyone's show. Essentially it's a little kid version of Xena (who also atones for having been bad).

reply

gay natiojn

reply