MovieChat Forums > Star Trek: Insurrection (1998) Discussion > Long live the glorious Baku! (Spoilers)

Long live the glorious Baku! (Spoilers)


A lot of posters here have argued the Federation has no right to relocate the Sona, because they became sovereign when they settled their "magic planet." But this overlooks the fact that the Baku do have that right!

The (conditionally) immortal Sona exiled the Baku to live out their natural lifespans and die. They apparently did this on the premise that the Sona became a legitimate government when they separated from their parent culture, and could therefore condemn their enemies to eventual death.

But then don't you have to accept that the Baku also became a legitimate government when they separated from their (literally) parent culture? If the Sona have the right to exile the Baku, stripping them of their immortality, on what grounds can the Baku not say, "We also became a sovereign people when we left to find our own way, just as you did, and we also have the right to take your immortality, just as you took ours?"

reply

[deleted]

What bothered me-- and it shoulda been obvious... The village doesn't take up much room. Plenty of space to build Federation Spas. hell, it's the SUN that does all the good stuff, build a RIngworld!

"After years of fighting with reality, I am pleased to say that I have finally won out over it."

reply

Bothers me too. You could settle 6 billion - hell with the Federation food and energy production tech double that - people on the planet and as long as you kept an exclusion zone of 20 to 50 miles (depending how high hiking figures among the Ba'ku's hobby list) around the village, and a no fly zone of a few hundred miles, the Ba'ku would never even know they where there.

reply

The Sona were the old angry race that was causing trouble, and the Baku were the peaceful villagers. You got it backwards.

- - - - - - -
Whose idea was it for the word "Lisp" to have an "S" in it?

reply