MovieChat Forums > The Wings of the Dove (1998) Discussion > Helena Bonham Carter should have been gi...

Helena Bonham Carter should have been given an Oscar


Helena Bonham Carter should have got the Oscar for best actress for her role in this wonderful film about love. I love the scene when she writes to Merton and says remember I love you more. It filled with emotion.

reply

[deleted]

Wasn't she amazing?

reply

Who says the academy awards has much to do with awarding the best in movies? Its more about politics and economics.

reply

I don't see why. She only has one expression.

reply

Helena Bonham Carter is an amazing actress. I am appalled that she did not win the Academy Award for her performance in "The Wings of the Dove", as she was brilliant!

reply

Yeah, I also don't agree. I don't think she should have won. I like her but that year was just really weak for female performances, including hers.

reply

I respectfully disagree. Helena Bonham Carter's performance made me truly sypmathize with her character...She did an amazing job of portraying the human emotions that lead Kate to make the choices she did.

I cannot begin to fathom how her performance was not recognized as the best of the year. It's all politics, I suppose...

reply

I have just finished watching Wings of the Dove and I am still shivering. Helena Bonham Carter's performance of decadence, love and fear is just heart breaking

reply

She would have been my second choice. Helen Hunt was just absolutely perfect in As Good as It Gets, full of layers and emotion.

"For the last time honey, there are no pirahannas in- MY BUTT!"- Tarzan

reply

[deleted]

Helen Hunt was just absolutely perfect in As Good as It Gets


Are you saying that Helen Hunt won an Oscar for the above movie? That movie was so crap, I had to bail out less than halfway through.

reply

The winner was Frances McDormand for Fargo not Helen Hunt

He had Like ESPN.
"No he had E-S-P. There's no N."-Life or Something Like it.

reply

Frances McDormand won the year before. Helena Bonham Carter was nominated alongside Judi Dench, Julie Christie, Kate Winslet, and Helen Hunt, at the 70th Academy Awards.

I just re-watched "The Wings of the Dove", and Helena was robbed of the Oscar!

reply

I love the scene when she writes to Merton and says remember I love you more. It filled with emotion.


I got shivers at that part. The look on her face when she says the 'remember I love you more' line has such an impact.

Helena Bonham Carter is my favourite actress and has been for quite some time. She was actually the reason I found out about this movie and wanted to watch it, and I'm so glad I did. Her performance was incredible. So deceiving and believable.

-----
I think I heard a click.
It was the gate,
It's the gate.
We don't have a gate.

reply

I agree completely, it would have been one of the most deserving Oscar wins. Such a breathtaking performance.

reply

I agree for the most part but found that the last scene in the bedroom, the acting of both HBC and LR was the most wooden I have seen for years!! Its like they just wanted to get filming over and done with and the characters seemed to be tolerating each other ...

reply

[deleted]

Carter’s gorgeous face is a telling kaleidoscope of emotions. She can register more with her eyes than most actors can with a whole script. In the film's penultimate scene stark naked in bed with Merton her whole body reflects the despair of Kate’s plots gone wrong. Now she has what she wanted, Merton and the fortune, which Millie has left to him. But Millie has left something else as well...the enfolding wings of the dove smothering Kate’s and Merton’s love into extinction shown in the paralysis of their lovemaking. Carter should have had the Oscar for that scene alone.

reply

I agree for the most part but found that the last scene in the bedroom, the acting of both HBC and LR was the most wooden I have seen for years!! Its like they just wanted to get filming over and done with and the characters seemed to be tolerating each other ...


You missed the point of that end scene. They were meant to appear as if they were just going through the motions but not the feelings, which had been irrevocably damaged.

reply

I just watched this and YES!

reply

yes

reply