She was so ordinary looking in this movie
...compared to how she looked in other movies.
shareTrue, but that's why they're called actors -- each role involves acting like a particular character within the context of the movie's setting/story.
shareI wasn't referring to her acting.
shareBut an actor's garb & make-up in a role are very much part of the acting -- the cinematic illusion to morph them into a wholly different person.
We know Bridget was still quite attractive when "A Simple Plan" was shot since she looked smoking in her previous movies -- "Jackie Brown" and "Finding Graceland." So her ordinary looks in "A Simple Plan" are the result of the all-around acting illusion, which includes her attire, make-up and demeanor.
I noticed it as well. Raimi and crew did a good job of making her up for exactly the role she was playing--a rural Midwestern wife.
While she may not have had the same hotness that she's had in other movies, she was still attractive and I imagine this may have been closer to her real-life everyday look.
It's a shame she quit acting. We lost her to retirement too soon.