MovieChat Forums > Starship Troopers (1997) Discussion > Zander being able to fight Rico on relat...

Zander being able to fight Rico on relatively equal terms Was stupid


The mobile infantry training is Essentially a specialized training all recruits are heavily trained in hand to hand combat yet Zander fought him on relatively equal terms which simply isn't realistic

just compare it to a Airman fighting a Navy seal, or green beret, delta force etc etc


just not going to happen

reply

That's what you find least realistic about this movie? Hilarious.

reply

Reminds me of when my friend was bitching in the theater about Naomi Watts being able to run through the woods barefoot, all while being pursued by a giant ape and a variety of prehistoric beasts.

http://jmoneyyourhoney.filmaf.com/owned

reply

It's like in the Battlestar Galactica reboot, when the best shot with a rifle in the fleet was not one of the marines, but a fighter pilot.

reply

This scene is not too bothering. . Johnny was highly emotional because of these girl issues, which weakened him as a soldier -- making him fight like a complete idiot.

reply

Yeah that never made sense to me.

And it seemed unfair, so Zander gets the girl, is obviously way smarter because he's a pilot, and he can go toe to toe with Rico in a fight?

What's Rico got left to compete?

reply

I'm sure Rico wasn't thinking clearly, since he was pissed (I know I wouldn't be able to in that situation) and perhaps Zander kept up his fitness - he played sports in school as well.

reply

The film doesn't show what kind of training pilots receive. As far as we know, Zandar could have been training in martial arts for ten years.

---
You got your mind right, Luke?

reply

Agreed. Plus, look at people today. I work with plenty of 8-5 business men who moonlight as amateur MMA fighters by night. Zander could have enjoyed working out, combat training, etc. He obvious knows how to fight, given that he is pretty aggressive with weapons when they crash land on the planet AND when they drop ship in to pick up the survivors from the outpost. Plus he was a bigger guy that little Casper.

reply