MovieChat Forums > G.I. Jane (1997) Discussion > Really Good Movie, Except for the Ending...

Really Good Movie, Except for the Ending......


I have always liked this movie except for the ending.

The whole movie is about her fighting to become a Navy Seal, but when she finally does that they ruin it by throwing in a quick little unnecessary battle scene at the end just to show she can fight.

The movie should have ended with her becoming a Navy Seal, that alone is the major accomplishment!
That is what the whole movie is about!

Can you imagine if at the end of An Officer and a Gentlemen after Mayo gets his salute he gets shipped out to some make believe battle just to show he is combat ready? I say BS!

The climatic ending should have been just her becoming a Navy Seal!





reply

I totally agree. The excitement and suspense was about watching her struggle through training and wondering if she would make it or not. We can pretty much take for granted that if she can pass navy seal training she can fight a battle. I was actually kinda bored watching the ending.

I also felt the same way about the ending to Top Gun with the dogfight scene. I know they needed some way to show that Maverick had gotten over his trauma but it just seemed unnecessary and too convenient. And the way they did it was pretty weak. He just suddenly "got over" his fear.

reply

I agree.

reply

The ending seemed tacked on and wasn't necessary. I too would have liked to have seen the movie end when she successfully completed the Seal training.



You remind me of him. You forget to remember to be afraid.

reply

[deleted]

She didn't become a Navy Seal. In the movie it depicts some fictitious CRT team training. It tries to recreate BUDS training. After BUDS training you aren't a Navy Seal, you are only a BUDS graduate. There are two more years of training before you are officially designated a Navy Seal...

...former Navy Petty Officer who was trained by UDT/SEALS...

reply

Thanks for the info.

I think it still would have been a better if they had left out the battle scene.



reply

I've only watched this ONCE,but I remember thinking that she should have shot and killed the master chief.Especially after he singled her out and beat her.Why wasn't he arrested for that?


I should have known those alien maggots booby trapped this sub

reply

They needed to tie in the fact that she COULD carry an injured soldier out of harm's way

reply

Too many movies about training have to tack on the usage of said training at the end of the film. Often it's contrived, and it has become cliche. Stripes did it. Every movie about kids going to space camp certainly has kids going into space...somehow. Top Gun, as mentioned.

A movie that did it realistically, though made it seem like two entirely different films was Full Metal Jacket. Not that it had to seem like a different film, but Vincent D'onofrio and R. Lee Ermy stole all the scenes in the first part of the film.

As they would uncreatively say on the Tropes website, "this trope was subverted" in the film Private Benjamin where Goldie Hawn leaves boot camp... to do pretty much nothing but screw some rich guy in Germany and then quit the Army.

A more realistic portrayal would be to show her finishing the training, and then skip some years down the road showing her using her training, perhaps in a top secret operation that required her analytic skills as well as direct combat training.

One reason movies often utilize the emergency call to arms trope where all the trainees are now the only hope, is that it's pretty much the only way you could justify all the same characters still being around and working together. Otherwise everyone would go their separate ways after training. Stripes ignored this logical aspect and instead had all the main characters go to exactly the same duty station after boot camp.

reply

[deleted]