MovieChat Forums > Fa yeung nin wah (2001) Discussion > Who was crying in the shower?

Who was crying in the shower?


After we find out that Mr. Chan was cheating with Mrs. Chow, there's a scene where a woman is crying in the shower - who is that, Mrs. Chow or Mrs. Chan (Maggie Cheung)?? It looks like a hotel room, but is it one of their apartments?

reply

That was Maggie.

reply

[deleted]

I'm pretty sure that was Chow. She'd just callously ended her affair with Chan, & is now regretting it.
Sequence of events was her on the phone with Chan, "Oh your wife's suspicion bothers you? Fine. Don't see me anymore." then a woman crying (with her hair cut) and then she & Chan are back together...

It was just a small scene, a small scene which explains why the affair continues, and why things don't work out so well. If the male Chan & female Chow just had their act together, they'd dump their spouses, leaving them free. However they don't, so they keep them hanging on.

reply

It was definitley Maggie Cheung. They make a point of not showing Mrs. Chow, and I do not see why the director would put a poignant scene of a woman crying in the shower for a character that is never properly shown in the film.

reply

for the same reason that you don't see her face in that scene

reply

Sorry, but I have to disagree. I can't remember the exact names, but I always thought it was Tony Leung's wife, since 1) her face is never shown, just as Maggie's husband's face is never shown, and 2) the hairstyle. In the first slow-mo sequence, you see Tony's wife go in and her hair is in that style. I think they maintained it and didn't get her hair wet to tell us it was Tony's unseen wife.

"Death, you are my bitch lover!"

reply

I think you are right too .. Tony's wife in the shower. I thought it was Maggie C., but clearly the hair is Tony's wife - knowing the mess was discovered.

reply

I agree. nice work.
cajun

reply

My hat, sir, is off.

reply

This a spectacular explanation. I admire your passion for this movie and for detail.

reply

[deleted]

Fighting with her lover .. she says to him in phone "did you talk to your wife" from subtitle -_-

reply

it's actually Mrs Chow .. don't you see her hair? her hair was shown previously for a little while and it was in the hotel after the shot of shower we see a man most probably Mr. Chan knocking at the door of the hotel with number 2048 i think :S

reply

[deleted]