MovieChat Forums > Yat goh ho yan (1998) Discussion > English or Cantonese?

English or Cantonese?

posted 16 years ago by go_titans
4 replies | jump to latest

hmm, not to active this particular board, but here goes anyway...

i'm wondering if Mr Nice Guy is supposed to be in english or cantonese? i have the impression it is supposed to be english - which is rare for a jackie chan film in the 90s.

i have it in widescreen with english audio but my copy has both english and cantonese subtitles permanently on the screen whether i want them or not!

this means i have to buy the dam thing again but before i do i want to make sure i have the proper audio.

so yeah, is it supposed to be english?

(you'd think imdb would have a section that clarifies that, but they don't.)

[–] armoreska 15 years ago

It does not look dubbed. English I say
edit: yes definitely English, only the scenes with his girlfriend are Cantonese. by the way anyone has subs to these?

www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=23949572 - vote history (>8500 titles)

[–] nglongjin 15 years ago

Actually, Jackie and his girlfriend were communicating in Mandarin. The dialogue between Jackie and the ice-cream man was in Cantonese.

[–] armoreska 15 years ago

oh thanks

www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=23949572 - vote history (>8500 titles)

[–] avortac4 (3752) 3 years ago

I was expecting it to be dubbed, but when I look at the guy with the moustache talk, it looks exactly like it would if he was actually talking in my opinion, so I agree, it doesn't look dubbed.