MovieChat Forums > Romeo + Juliet (1996) Discussion > What caused the fight with Montagues and...

What caused the fight with Montagues and Capulets?


They don't really say in the play really,so i was curious? Also,what do you think would've happened if their families found out about the marriage before they died?

reply

William Shakespeare never mentioned why the two houses were fighting so it's anyone's guess. Chances are it was something going back a long time since it seemed to be old news to the rest of the town.

What would've happened after the marriage was revealed is also anyone's guess. Personally, I think the families would've made up or at least come to a tolerance of each other since the the two fathers immediately reconciled after seeing the devastation their feuding had cause.

reply

It is never stated why the two families are arguing. In all possibility, it is a feud that has lasted generations, so not even the modern day families know why they are fighting, they just know that the other family is their enemy.

reply

There is an author named Donald Miller who supposed that they were fighting about the old 'Catholic vs. Protestant' thing that was so enduring in England at that time. It kind of is a 'Face-saver' that he doesn't really point it out, though, isn't it?

reply

In the prologue, Shakespeare refers to the feud as an 'ancient grudge' so it has presumably been passed down through the generations. As is so often the case, the original cause may well have been forgotten over possibly hundreds of years,

reply

Can't be it. The play is set in Italy. Catholics ruled there and plus the grudge was ancient at the time the play was written, the Protestants were only near 100 years old.

Tangled up since 12/31/10

reply

I think Shakespeare intentionally left out the cause of the feud, to make the conflict in the play seem even more empty and absurd.

reply

'I think Shakespeare intentionally left out the cause of the feud, to make the conflict in the play seem even more empty and absurd. '

Good point.

reply

Comparably to the Hatfields and McCoys, no one actually knows and think it not being revealed to us, further drives the point home of it being a dated, insignificant conflict.

reply

No reason is given for the feud. They have apparently been at odds forever. They would have made Juliet get an annulment and marry Paris. Or they might have realized that Romeo and Juliet were an acceptable match and made peace overtures to each other.






"Joey, have you ever been in a Turkish prison?"

reply

Montague is a Mac. Capulet is a PC.

reply

Of course it falls apart when you realize Macs are Pc's.

reply



~Memories made in the coldest winter~

reply

Someone stole someone else's goat and it escalates over generations.

People don't like to be meddled with.

reply