MovieChat Forums > Last Man Standing (1996) Discussion > Comparison to 'Fistful of Dollars' and '...

Comparison to 'Fistful of Dollars' and 'Yojimbo'


One of Kurosawa’s masterpiece Yojimbo is a movie dealing with his favorite subject – a Japanese history. Although its historical context, some critics clamed it was a metaphor of a cold war between US and Soviet Union, and some of them that it was a western-parody. In any case, this action drama is an excellent movie working fine on many levels, for both the critics and the wider audience.

However, Leone’s piece was loved by audience but ignored by the critics at first, mostly because of his two-dimensional characters. But the review during the years changed that opinion, and today it’s a known fact that no one dealt better with that types of characters than Leone. His cartoon characters most of the cartoon-haters love to watch. However, this part of the ‘Man with no name’ trilogy is considered to be the weakest part, but still a solid spaghetti western.

The ‘Last man standing’ is the worst of these three films by far. Seems that Walter Hill has lost his touch from the seventies and eighties. The movie is directed as a routine and the same goes for the leading actors. Christopher Walken is standard Christopher Walken, and Willis’ character reminds me of the comic character Torpedo. But the routine of the director is below average.


Movie remakes compared to original
http://www.movie-remakes.com

reply

yeah ive watched a fistfull of dollars today and i tought that this movie was VERY familiar.

Last man standing is a total rip-off

reply

Of course it's familiar. It's called a remake, not a rip-off.

reply

[deleted]

I thought "last man standing" was much better than I expected. Better than most other action movies. The one thing that bothered me most was the narrating. The narrating ruined Bruce Willis character by making him seem mortal. In Yojimbo and fistful of dollars, Clint and Mifune stayed tough and kept their thought for themselves, which in a way made them seem invincible. I also thought it was ridiculous how many times willis shot at a person, kept going even after he was dead.

reply

[deleted]

Actually, he is using two Colt 1911s, which hold a maximum of seven shots in the magazine, one in the chamber (in the twenties they didn't have high capacity magazines). But that's beside the point; I thought this movie was entertaining, and I liked how someone finally set the story in the twenties (when Red Harvest was set). I will admit, the movie itself is a little goofy, but I found it entertaining none the less.

reply

[deleted]

"And where hell does he get all those clips?"

There's a sequence where he loads a bunch of them up. He gets free refills.

And while LAST MAN STANDING isn't as good as YOJIMBO, for me it's far more entertaining and just flat out better than A FISTFUL OF DOLLARS - the weakest of Leone's westerns that's hindered by the narrow scope of it's source material.

LAST MAN STANDING is one of the last great tough guy movies and one of Walter Hill's best. Beautifully stylized and sorely underrated.

reply

FRom the OP,
"The ‘Last man standing’ is the worst of these three films by far."

Duh, your comparing Leone and Kurosawa to Walter Hill! What did you expect?

When you laugh, the world laughs with you. when you weep, you weep alone.

reply

To me "Lat man standing" is the best by far. And yeah! Leone is overrated.

reply

To me "Lat man standing" is the best by far.

I agree, but I think it's mostly because I prefer gangster movies to Westerns and never even watch Samurai movies. Plus, I like Bruce Willis.

It's almost exactly the same story in three different contexts, so it's more about the actors and the background setting than the story itself, IMO. Wonder what the next remake'll be?


There's a plan in everything, kid. And I love it when a plan comes together!

reply