Special Forces?


Are these guys Delta Force or Green Berets? The patches on their arms threw me off.

reply

I think they were US Amry Special Forces, maybe Delta Force,

reply

My uncle is in Special Forces and whenver you are takin about anything like Navy SEALs or Delta Force they are know as SOF Special Operation Forces, Special Forces are the Green Berets.

reply

I pressumed they were Delta since Steven Segals rank is Colonel which is an army rank, if they were Seals then he would have been a Commander which is the Navy equivalent of Colonel isn't it?

reply

They're not the Delta Force. The Delta Force do not salute each other as far as I know and I'm pretty sure some of them did in this movie.

Meh!

reply

Hmmm...wikipedia refers to hem as commandos so wouldn't that be Green Berets?

reply

The film refers to them as US Army Special Forces, depending on how much you know about Special Forces, you can come to the assumption that these are Delta Force soldiers. Delta Force is used more commonly in urban/residential/hijacking than the Green Berets who are used in more rural/enemy held terrain.

Green Berets soldiers would not be ordered to infiltrate and evac drugs/nerve agents from an urban building, such as the one featured in the beginning of this movie.

But then again, it's a movie.

reply

The patch that was visible on Segal's left shoulder was clearly that of Special Forces, not Delta (*a.k.a. USSOCOM - 1SFOD-D/CAG)

The patch is an arrow-head, with a dagger and 3 lightning bolts. Above that was three rocker tabs for "Special Forces", "Airborne" and "Ranger". That is typical of the US Army's Special Forces, a.k.a. "The Green Berets"

The Patch for Delta is similar - an arrow-head with a dagger, but no lightning bolts. Delta will also typically only a single "Airborne" rocker tab above the patch.

In my opinion, this is an error, either by the writer's or perhaps the wardrobe dept., as the scenario depicted in the film would most likely be assigned to Delta in real life.



(*United States Special Operations Command - First Special Forces Operation Detachment - Delta, also known as the 'Combat Applications Group')

Wolf



"I Drank What?!" - Socrates

reply

1. Delta ARE Army Special Forces aka "Green Berets". Formed to be the US's answer to counter terrorism following the Munich olympics debacle. Formed by and first commanded by Colonel "Charging Charlie" Beckwith in the mid-70s. First used in the aboted Operation Eagle Claw designed to rescue Americans held hostage in Iran. SF is employed in "perational detachments" or ODs. The basic group is known as OD A (16 men) and is often referred to in movies as an A Team. Having recently returned from duty in Afghanistan I can tell you that no one refers to OD As as "A Teams". They are ODAs - pure and simple. The next level up is OD B (approx 75 men). When Beckwith needed to name his new, counter terrorist unit, he chose to call it OD D, hence the name "Delta" which represents the letter D in the military phoenetic alphabet.

2. Delta are trained for counter terrorism while typical SF ODAs etc are supposed to be used to train indigenous forces in insurgencies. Since Vietnam, SF role has expanded beyond that. Anyway, given the terrorist nature of the baddies in this movie, Delta would be the choice to deal with them. Therefore, the good guys in this film are supposed to be Delta.

3. The term "SOF" as mentioned earlier is a general term to refer to all SOF assets: SF, SEALs, USMC Force Recon, Rangers, AF PJs and SF Aviation (SOAR).

4. As is pointed out in the Goofs section, Delta would not be wearing ANY patches on their uniforms when doing an assault. That said, Delta belongs to Army SF so it is plausible that a senior officer attending a meet would have an SF patch on his "non-sterilized" working uniform.

5. To answer the earlier question about navy vs army ranks: an army Colonel would be a navy Captain. An army Lieutenant Colonel would be a navy Commander.

reply

Yes, here is a nice article on Operation Eagle Claw:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Eagle_Claw

*********************************************

Sig Line:

Many cynics and skeptics mistake their hubris negativity for actual intelligence.

reply

Delta Force is often referred to as Special Forces Operational Detachment-Delta. It's also known as the Combat Applications Group (CAG). While it often draws its ranks from the Army Special Forces (the Army Green Berets) and shares Fort Bragg, N.C., headquarters with them, it isn't an Army Special Forces detachment. Delta Force is a unit unto itself, composed of members from all branches of the military.

They're not called soldiers, but operators and are said to shun the traditional philosophies of military life. They wear civilian clothes. They work for whomever needs them -- for the Army, the FBI and the CIA. Generally speaking anyone in Delta Force hates the traditional army way of life, it's politics.

Delta Force recruits are selected based on the special skills they possess, like exceptional marksmanship. It's reported (?) that Delta Force recruits must show 100 percent accuracy in shooting from 600 yards, and 90 percent accuracy at 1,000 yards.

Delta Force is separated into three combat squadrons -- A, B and C -- along with a support squadron, signal squadron, aviation platoon and a "funny platoon" -- the intelligence-gathering outfit of the Delta Force, rumored to be the only special operations platoon to include women.

Generally speaking no one within the armed services acknowledges the existence of Delta Force but with all of the recent exploits overseas with Navy Seals most people just assume they exist.

Ranks:


E-5 Sergeant SGT Be assigned to Squad Leader
E-6 Staff Sergeant SSG
E-7 Sergeant First Class SFC
E-8 First Sergeant (Master Sergeant)
E-9 Sergeant Major (Command Sergeant Major)

Not able to go higher...




I could tell you how I know but then I might have to kill you.

reply

"Special Forces are made up of Army Delta, Marine Force Recon and the Naval community.... so basically they are from everywhere except the Air Force"

Technically wrong.

What you are describing is SOF (Special operations Forces) and not the SF. Subtle difference, but, words matter.

The SF is Army Special Forces (often referred to in civilian circles as Green Berets). Delta is part of SF (as I explained earlier).

Each branch of the service has its own spec ops organization that falls under the umbrella of SOC:

a. Army = SF (including Delta). Also 75th Ranger Regiment which fall under SOC coord but are not considered on the same tier as SF;

b. Navy = SEALs;

c. Marine Corps = Force Recon; and

d. Airforce = 160 SOAR (Special Ops Aviation Regiment) and the PJs (combat search and rescue jumpers - depicted in Blackhawk Down).

All that together = SOF.

reply

[deleted]

@libertarian45

Technically wrong.

What you are describing is SOF (Special operations Forces) and not the SF. Subtle difference, but, words matter.

The SF is Army Special Forces (often referred to in civilian circles as Green Berets). Delta is part of SF (as I explained earlier).

Each branch of the service has its own spec ops organization that falls under the umbrella of SOC:

a. Army = SF (including Delta). Also 75th Ranger Regiment which fall under SOC coord but are not considered on the same tier as SF;

b. Navy = SEALs;

c. Marine Corps = Force Recon; and

d. Airforce = 160 SOAR (Special Ops Aviation Regiment) and the PJs (combat search and rescue jumpers - depicted in Blackhawk Down).

All that together = SOF.






160th SOAR is an Army unit, NOT an Air Force unit. Also, I'm not sure about Force Recon's role/status these days since the formation of MSOR a few years ago. BTW, Delta and The Green Berets are NOT the same or even part of the same unit. I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure that as an SMU, Delta (along with ST6/DEVGRU or whatever they're calling themselves these days in addition to a handful of other classified SMUs) is controlled by JSOC whereas the GB's are not.

reply

"160th SOAR is an Army unit, NOT an Air Force unit. Also, I'm not sure about Force Recon's role/status these days since the formation of MSOR a few years ago. BTW, Delta and The Green Berets are NOT the same or even part of the same unit. I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure that as an SMU, Delta (along with ST6/DEVGRU or whatever they're calling themselves these days in addition to a handful of other classified SMUs) is controlled by JSOC whereas the GB's are not. "

Bruddah Matt,

Good points all.

1. 160 SOAR. I come from a country that has only airforce and no army aviation. That's my excuse. In my brain, if it flies, it's AF. Mind you, I worked last year with a very capable female pilot who would have kicked me in the junk if she heard me refer to Army Avn as AF.

2. Marines. You are correct. The Marine Special Ops regiment was formed in 2007. I met a few of them last year as well, but, forgot they were no longer Force Recon.

3. Delta Force = army and although they have SF in the title, are considered a Special Mission Unit (along with SEAL Team 6/DEVGRU) in Joint Special Ops Command. When Charlie Beckwith formed the SFOD-D, I believe it was part of the SF (green berets).

4. The current breakdown of SOF is:

a. Army - US Army SOC = SF (green Bs), 75th Ranger regt, 160 SOAR;

b. USMC - Marine SOCOM = Marine Special Ops Regiment;

c. Navy - Nav Spec warfare Command = SEAL Teams (minus SEAL Tm 6) and spec warfare crewmen;

d. Air Force - AF Spec Ops Command = various wings and groups of aircraft along with the afore mentioned PJs, Combat Controllers, Tactical air control parties and spec ops weather.

e. Special Mission Units - under Joint Spec Ops Command = Army - 1st SFOD (Delta); Navy - Naval Spec Warfare Development Group (DEVGRU) or SEAL tm 6; Air Force - 24th Spec Tactics Squadron.

The Wikipedia entries on all the above are quite good, actually.




reply

[deleted]

I am not even going to pretend to be as knowledgeable as you, but if you look in the situation room when the realization is made that the assault team is still operational, Charles Hallahan's character is wearing the Delta dress insignia, red background with sword and the Airborne tab above it. I believe these is referred to as the USASOC patch? His character also has the Ranger tab above that. So wouldn't it be plausible to think that someone involved with Delta is involved with the mission? Again, not an expert, but just throwing an idea out.

reply

U.S. Military Special Operations are under the command of
United States Special Operations Command
Consisting of the following units

U.S. Army: United States Army Special Operations Command
75th Ranger Regiment
United States Army Special Forces (delta force is included in the Special Forces)
160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment
4th Military Information Support Group
95th Civil Affairs Brigade
528th Sustainment Brigade

U.S. Navy: United States Naval Special Warfare Command
Marine Corps: United States Marine Corps Forces Special Operations Command
United States Navy SEALs
Naval Special Warfare Development Group (aka seal team 6 reallocated DEVGRU in 1987)
SEAL Delivery Vehicle Teams
Special Warfare Combatant-craft Crewmen
Marine Raider Regiment
Marine Intelligence Battalion
Marine Special Operations Support Group


U.S.: Air Force Air Force Special Operations Command
Combat Control Teams
Pararescuemen
Special Operations Weather Technicians

The red arrowhead with a dagger patch is of the United States Army Special Operations Command it is a command patch

The only ranks you will not find in U.S. Army SOF is E-4 and below there are generals that are SOF.
Former U.S. Army 5th SFG SFC

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]