MovieChat Forums > Silent Witness (1996) Discussion > Nikki, Jack and Clarissa -- series 18 o...

Nikki, Jack and Clarissa -- series 18 observations


I almost gave up on series 17 last year when Nikki, Jack and Clarissa had no real connection to one another as close 3-part team (the way Nikki once had with Leo and Harry.)

And last year's stories were okay, IMHO, but not great. So last year it was nothing interesting happening with the stars, and no story, too. Bah.

But this year, wow. Each story so far as been amazing--like feature film quality stuff.

Now I can see what the writers are doing? Have they decided to veer away from the inner lives of the main characters or anything about their teaming up and being friends, to just use them as background for the intense stories they are telling with superlative plots and guest stars?

That's the only thing I can come up with for why, for instance, in his third series, we know absolutely NOTHING and I mean NOTHING, about Jack? No girlfriend? No boyfriend? He's from Norn Irn and does cage fighting. Three series and that's it? Who is this guy? I'm still wanting to know.

He had no inner life in these past 3 series.

The closest we got to any kind of human behavior from Jack was last week when he was cruising around the office subtly trying to cock-block the dishy police inspector Luke Nelson who was spending time with Nikki on his own personal case from his childhood! haha Finally. Some human behavior from Jack.

As for Nikki, I guess they just decided to accept she's got relationship issues and just hint she dates sometimes (like leaving the origami bird with her mobile number on it for the jogger who seemed to turn up all the time when she was running).

And is Chamberlain's character anything but wallpaper?

Even Clarissa isn't given enough lines! More Clarissa please. At least in the last 2 series, she was always giving Jack some smart cracks, bringing him up to snuff.

I'd love to see a scene in which Jack and Nikki are working late (because let's face it they have no life, ha), and Clarissa says "Well, I'm out of here and you two are on your own. I have a date.." When she smiles and wheels out to meet her dishy date waiting in the lobby.

Oh well, this series is good.

But I do miss the camaraderie and closeness and personal stories of the 3-person team they wove into the stories when we had Leo, Harry and Nikki. Sigh.

reply

I just came on here to write the same thing..............

Series 17, dull. Series 18 - amazing. However, it's now become mostly the Emilia Fox show (which, fortunately, I don't mind as I love her character) with Jack becoming the lesser sidekick. Clarissa and Chamberlain - they barely even register this series, which is an absolute waste of two fine actors.

Can we just dig up Leo??? :-)

reply

I agree series 18 is much better than the last, which I actually didn't finish. I am quite pleased that Jack is taking a more backseat role as I've never liked the character (too much of a policeman rather than scientist). I wouldn't mind seeing more Clarissa & especially Chamberlain with him being the most esteemed pathologist!

I think Emilia Fox needs a counterbalance though. I think Chamberlain could be the one to be that counterbalance.

reply

Series 18 is well back on form (and I never thought I'd say that after Harry left). It's enjoyable again. Every episode has been tense, well acted, less graphic and interesting.

I'm actually liking Jack a lot this year and enjoying his seeming partnership with Nikki. - loved the annoyance (jealousy?) he had with Nelson

My only question is, is Tom even still in this show?

reply

Yes, agree, Jack is marginally more likeable this year. And as I said above, at last, he finally showed some human behavior over his Alpha Male response to the other Alpha who entered his den. LOL

The last two series, Jack's character was like some harsh bully boy with attitude but no inner life to soften him up. He was single dimensional. At least they could have given us some of his demons? But none ever arrived to explain his harsh personality. The existence of his beloved Clarissa in his life was the only hint he was human! ha

Well, from the previews, it looks like he is finally going to show the folks he has a (male) pulse. He was making eyes at the female cop. But we probably were not privy to the next scene in which she probably tells Jack she doesn't play for the team that finds him shaggable. LOL

Poor Jack. Can't seem to get a leg over.

reply

Well, from the previews, it looks like he is finally going to show the folks he has a (male) pulse. He was making eyes at the female cop.

even better than that paradesend .. Jack is wearing a woman's robe at her flat in a clip from the upcoming block!

http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p02hdyz0

reply

Agree! I live in the US so we don't get Silent Witness over here but I have a few friends in the UK who tell me they're fans of the show and since I love crime dramas, for me to check it out. So I did last year and could not, for the life of me, get into it. Guess it was just bad luck that I saw Series 17 first. This year, however, I chanced upon Series 18 when there was nothing else to watch and found myself thoroughly enjoying it. So much, that I even made the effort to seek out earlier episodes (series 10-14). I hope they'll continue with the improved writing.

reply

Yes, it would be much more gratifying NOT to begin with IMHO, the weakest moment in the entire history of the series--series 16 and 17--with the arrival of Jack and Chamberlain, who are not a patch on the beloved Leo and Harry, as Nikki's sidekicks.

Thankfully, series 18 has rebooted the franchise to great.

I've watched it since the original with doc Sam Ryan played by Amanda Burton. But seeing a few again from the original, has a strong dated feeling as they go back to the mid-90s. But if you don't mind that, they are great, too.

And this show has morphed from a more simplistic procedural with autopsies from an Oxford location, to a full-out police/forensic London-based drama that has become more sophisticated as the years went on.

I'd recommend if you can access old episodes, to begin with the first one where Nikki arrives, all young and eager and gamin like. ha

It would be hard to imagine never having Nikki, Leo and Harry in my life on their crime adventures.

As said elsewhere, this 18th series seems to have put the star characters, Nikki, Jack and Chamberlain on the backburner with regard to their daily and personal lives, and just written major plots with amazing guest stars who are the centerpieces of the show this year.

It's like Nikki, Jack, Clarissa and Chamberlain are just sidekicks in their own show now! haha Whereas before, the stars had personal plot lines and things.

But 18 is still great. The writing and acting and plots are feature film quality this year.

reply

What episode was it that she left the origami bird? I must have missed those few minutes somehow.

reply

Snipers Nest SE18 E01 & 02
'tler

reply