MovieChat Forums > Judge Judy (1996) Discussion > More Outrageous reasoning from Judge Jud...

More Outrageous reasoning from Judge Judy (10-25)


Once again, Judy's disdain for the small business owner has reared it's ugly head.

In the 10-25 case of the couple who sold their hairdressing business after six months, JJ said at least three times (if not more) "No one sells a successful business!"

Dear God, can this woman ever be more wrong?

As a small business owner of 25 years, I can assure you plenty of successful businesses have been sold - from small mom&pop stores (like they owned) to major corporations. The best business to sell is a successful one, rather than a failed one. It's like her saying "No one sells their home in a very desirable neighborhood with property values way up."

There are dozens of reasons why a person would sell a successful business other than the fact that it's the most opportune time for them...

1. The business is owner/operator like the hair salon (and my own store), and it's not for the ones who can't devote 24/7 over the first five years - like this woman.

2. For whatever reason, the owner is moving away from the state/city/location.

3. Major change in the owner's life (starting a family; divorce; death of someone close; spouse's job relocation, etc).

4. Realization you like working with people but not the public every day.

5. You find you really have a stronger passion for something other than what you chose (in this case, the woman wanted to return to nursing school).

(It's like a student dropping out of college with a 4.0 average because he/she has other circumstances in their life...you don't drop out of college only if you're failing!)

But JJ really tried to hammer that the business was a failure and that's why they had to sell. The fiance kept saying 'No, it was not a failure' because he wasn't going to let JJ bully him. She then said 'Well, it wasn't meeting expectations' - which he admitted was true in a sense, because it became a one woman show for his girlfriend (she was supposed to have a partner helping out) who had no more time for herself or her daughter....so in a sense, it was true it didn't meet her personal expectations but met financial expectations - which made Judge Judy more furious.

Not to mention JJ, 6 months is not nearly long enough to gauge if a new business is successful or not - three years is usually the minimum.

JJ really needs to take a few courses on small businesses, interview many who have been self-employed for a while, and drop that anger and attitude towards small business owners.

"Splodey heads keep splodin' " - Sarah Palin, 7-1-16 ๎€š







reply

I found her to be very rude. As you say businesses are sold for many reasons other than failure. She needs to learn to step in another person's shoes for a second and realize just because some business fail it doesn't mean every business fails.

<โ€œEvery man of courage is a man of his word.โ€ - Pierre Corneille>

reply

Agreed, she's just a b**ch, her show is on when I get home from work and it's like a train wreck.... awful but I can't look away. I can't stand the way she speaks to people. She makes up her own version of events and once she does that no matter what the plaintiff or defendant have to say will change her mind despite the fact that SHE WAS NOT THERE!

reply

She needs to learn to step in another person's shoes for a second and realize just because some business fail it doesn't mean every business fails.


Obviously, neither she nor any family member has ever owned their own small business on their own, delivering a service to the community. I know her brother is a dentist, but don't know whether he is in private practice or not.

"Splodey heads keep splodin' " - Sarah Palin, 7-1-16 ๎€š







reply