MovieChat Forums > The Net (1995) Discussion > This movie proves anyone can steal your ...

This movie proves anyone can steal your life


This movie proves anyone can steal your life... IF:
*You have no friends or relatives who know you
*Somehow you don't manage to have any contact with your neighbors
*You don't go to the doctor or dentist (who would have your health records)
*You work from home and are a shut in
*You don't bother with such things as a passport or other ID that would be on file
*Doesn't seem to know the people who take care of your sick mother!!!! This latter one seems like a huge problem!

Yeah, I know the movie came out in 1995. But it is yet another lazy premise that the writer thinks is clever. Then to make it work has to remove so many situations that the person is no longer a "normal" person.

And it is total laziness. An easier fix would have been to have the main character recently relocate across country, so that solves the doctor/dentist/friends/relatives problem. But instead we're left with a character that somehow has no contact with real people. Yet keeps in shape, has a current haircut and normal clothes! Wow, for a shut in with little social contact she looks normal.


reply

Angela is very reclusive, but that doesn't mean she doesn't keep in shape thanks to exercise videos she orders online/phone or cut her own hair and style it after pictures of women she sees online.

reply

i know alot of people who play WoW and would fit pretty much all these arguments.

but that isn't a big deal. these people erased her life. it would be easy to pretend to be someone else if you never ran into anyone they know. even then, if you wanted to steal someone's identity, you could act as them even around people they knew since most people don't have constant access to other people's records.

if you wanted to really rip someone off, it is entirely possible. what they did in the movie would require someone to be completely cut off from the rest of the world, which is possible, but not probable.

reply

Yep this movie is one big case of identity theft.

reply

This movie is all about having your ID stolen due to the advances in technology. In 1995 this could have been possible for terrorists as encryption was not that advanced


This movie proves anyone can steal your life... IF:

*You have no friends or relatives who know you

She worked from home and spoke only to people over the phone where she worked from. She had only moved in few months and her character was pretty much keep herself to herself, she tried the reach out to someone she new and it got them killed, she would not do that again.

*Somehow you don't manage to have any contact with your neighbors

She had only moved in few months and her character was pretty much keep herself to herself. I personally can't stand my neighbours, thats not really unrealistic.


*You don't go to the doctor or dentist (who would have your health records)

She did which were all altered to Ruth Marx by the praetorians

*You work from home and are a shut in

Which she is, she is a top computer analyzer

*You don't bother with such things as a passport or other ID that would be on file

Again all changed by the praetorians, Plus they gave her a wanted by police and criminal record. Which would have put her in custody, where the predorians would come and collect her and kill her.


*Doesn't seem to know the people who take care of your sick mother!!!! This latter one seems like a huge problem!

She seeks help from anyone that new her she would get them killed, plus she has a criminal record, even if a nurse ID'd her, she would flag up as wanted the police would believe there system not a wanted person and they would amend the nurse who ID'd her’s doctors record to have a drug problem and police record and give her some minor charges in assault and she would be sacked never to work in care again.

Yet keeps in shape

She Jogs.

a current haircut

When you go for a hair cut you say your name.

normal clothes

Again why would a sales adviser know her name.

All 3 of them would not proove she is Angela Bennett.

This day and age this would never happen, but would have been possible. But back in 1995 we were vulnerable with the internet, I myself downloaded a program, went in to a chat room which used to give username and IP which gave you straight access to the persons computer.

reply

Sorry, I still don't buy it. I work from home, and have for most of my adult life. I still manage to know my neighbors.

And my doctors and dentists would know me, and probably have things like dental records saved locally. This computer thing can't change everything.

My point is still that it is extremely sloppy. Basically they have to steal the identity of a character that really matches no one. As I said I work from home, but people know me.

Another case of a good premise that doesn't really make sense, so the writers get lazy and after painting themselves into a corner come up with silly ways out. As I said, your identity can be stolen if and then I name the reasons why. I wasn't saying these were reasons why her identity couldn't be stolen, I was saying these were the reasons it would be harder.

reply

But like you said, Angela Bennett is not you. You go out to meet your neighbors; Angela does not.

She prefers to stay at home, play Second Life and WoW, and order pizza from Papa John's and maybe groceries from Vons.com.

Angela then rents exercise DVDs from Netflix (she likes the streaming), and probably cuts her own hair. She likes to read directions from eHow.com or maybe looks at some YouTube videos.

She brushes her teeth regularly and doesn't need to go to the doctor cuz she uses Wrongdiagnosis.com

reply

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

But the point is that anyone can steal your life IF you meet those restrictions. When this movie came out it was another, "imagine how anyone can steal your life...."

The point is that it would be really hard, or impossible for anyone to actually pull this off. It is sort of like the movie Firewall.

Yeah, this thing can happen to YOU... (but disclaimer: a lot of strange/surreal/improblemable things need to be in place for it to actually happen to you.)

reply

[deleted]