Dreadful Film


So many holes, so much loathing. Another poster in another thread said that if they addressed the many and sundry holes in the story there would be no story, so true and nothing of value would have been lost. Predictable, unnecessary, and ultimately a sum of zero, really, what was the point? How this film became "critically acclaimed" is truly astonishing. A better story would have been one of Sara and her father's adventures in India, or anywhere else in the world for that matter. Sara's father could have met a kinder Ms. Minchin who would have then became Sara's truly loving new mother, and everyone would have had a happy ending. But oh, no, not enough adversity there, let's just go with a transparent and boring formula. No small wonder this film was a box office flop.

reply

You realize this was based off a book, right?



EMOTICONS ARE BACK! YAY!   

reply

Unfortunately, this version has little to do with the book

reply

It does have a lot of differences from the book, but the main plot points are basically still there. Plus the things that the OP is specifically complaining about are the same in the book and the movie.

reply

Frantastic_Miss_Fox

Bravo!.... I couldn't say it better.

reply