4 Gallons


I can't hold onto the solution to that riddle - and I'm a math guy. I know that there are 2 ways to do it, and I understand and compute them both, but it always messes with me. Hate it...

"I do not like mixing up moralities and mathematics."
Churchill

reply

[deleted]

I had a good buzz on while I was watching it last night but I made myself think about how to do it over and over (through the confusion) til I had the first method figured out. Had it down first thing this morning. Second way is better though, hadn't thought about that way. Ty for the response ;)

"I do not like mixing up moralities and mathematics."
Churchill

reply

in the movie they don't show John and Zeus doing all the process

reply

... they don't show John and Zeus doing all the process
May be not to save time, but the solution they come up with is correct.🐭

reply

[deleted]

Best way to do it though is to fill the 3 gallon jug, then empty it into the 5 gallon jug. Then repeat, fill 3 gallon jug and empty into 5 gallon jug. 5 gallon jug will be filled leaving 1 gallon of water left in the 3 gallon jug.

Then empty out the 5 gallon jug. Pour the 1 gallon of water from the 3 gallon jug into the 5 gallon jug and then refill the 3 gallon jug again and pour that into the 5 gallon jug giving you exactly 4 gallons of water in the 5 gallon jug.

reply

Yes, I came here to write down that very same solution.

reply

no the easiest is fill the 5. fill the 3 from the 5. empty the three. pour the 2 left in the 3 gallon. fill the 5 again dump out the gallon into the 3. much faster.

reply

Best way to do it though is to fill the 3 gallon jug, then empty it into the 5 gallon jug. Then repeat, fill 3 gallon jug and empty into 5 gallon jug. 5 gallon jug will be filled leaving 1 gallon of water left in the 3 gallon jug.

Then empty out the 5 gallon jug. Pour the 1 gallon of water from the 3 gallon jug into the 5 gallon jug and then refill the 3 gallon jug again and pour that into the 5 gallon jug giving you exactly 4 gallons of water in the 5 gallon jug.

That is the simplist way of doing that. The way they did it in the movie is more complicated. Here is how they did it.
They fill the 5 gallon jug to the top. They fill the 3 gallon jug with said 5 gallon container. They now have 2 gallons in the 5 gallon jug. Pour out the 3 gallons in the 3 gallon jug. Pour the 2 gallons into the 3 gallon. Fill the 5 gallon jug and dump 1 gallon into the 3 gallon jug filled with 2 gallons to get 4 gallons. Obviously the film makers wanted to use the more complex method. Also the method the guy above used would've taken a little less time as it involves dumping 9 gallons as opposed to the one they used in the movie that involves dumping out 10.
1, 2 Freddy's coming for you. 3, 4 better lock your door.

reply

Actually I just realized a flaw in what I wrote. Both methods involve a lot of pouring and filling.

Fill 5 gallons 3 gallons 2 gallons 5 gallons and 1 gallon
Dump 3 gallons 2 gallons, 1 gallon.

Fill 3 gallons, 2 gallons, 1 gallon, 3 gallons
Dump 3 gallons, 2 gallons, 5 gallons, 1 gallon, 3 gallons,

Both are really time consuming. I can't seem to be able to tell which method is actually less time consuming.

reply

Today I was watching the movie, and before they solved it in the movie, which I have no idea how they did, I think that if you fill the five gallon jug full, then pour it all over into the three jug, you get 2 gallons remaining... DAMNIT I need two three gallon jugs for my solution to work because you need to do that two times. False alarm everybody. I didn't solve it.

reply

😂😂😂

"I do not like mixing up moralities and mathematics."
Churchill

reply

It would be fun for a grade school or highschool teacher to actually give this riddle to his or her kids to solve as extra credit in math.

1, 2 Freddy's coming for you. 3, 4 better lock your door.

reply

It's so easy. Fill up the 5 gallon jug and use it to fill up the 3 gallon jug. Throw away the water in the 3 gallon jug. Now pour the 2 gallon that's left in the 5 gallon jug into the 3 gallon jug. Then fill up the 5 gallon jug again and use it to fill up the 3 gallon jug. You've now got 4 gallon left in the 5 gallon jug.

reply

Wouldnt it just be easier to have a 4 gallon jug?

reply

Well, yes but the bad guy is big on riddles and liked testing John's and Zeus' skills. So he gives them a way that's more complicated.

reply

joke fell flat....:)

reply