I feel that a Greg counterpart would be more difficult to cast than the others simply because Barry Williams had a very distinctive kind of face. It's harder to find someone else who looks like him.
I think most of the other kids have a more generic appearance, though I am still amazed that the movie version of Marcia looked almost like the exact twin of the original Marcia.
I do agree, however, that Barnes didn't act that much like the orginal Greg. The original Greg was a pretty confident, assured kind of guy. He seemed to carry some authority on account of being the oldest child, but not so much in the movie. That grinning and geeky manner actually reminds me more of the way the original Peter acted in the later episodes of the series.
That being said, however, I still feel that the movie-Greg did create many funny moments. I could forgive the movie for deviating from the original somewhat on one character, since the others were more faithful. But if the movie had deviated that much on more of the characters, it wouldn't have been nearly as good a movie.
reply
share