MovieChat Forums > Ellen (1994) Discussion > Refer to sitcom: was ellen always gay in...

Refer to sitcom: was ellen always gay in all seasons?


I don't remember the first season too much, but I heard that the first season ellen morgan was straight? Have no clue but if anyone knows that would be awesome.

reply

i'm sure Ellen Morgan had always been gay but she didn't realize it until season 4 the season she came out. but no 1st-3rd season she dated men.

~~Jessica~~

reply

[deleted]

yep thats sooooooooo true! i also think she looks alot younger now that shes older other then vise versa. am i the only one who sees that???/ anyone else agree.

~~Jessica~~

reply

The character dated men during seasons 1 & 2. During season 3 she was completely dateless and during season 4 that fact was commented on by more characters than just her mother being unhappy about Ellen not having a man, like in the first seasons.

I don't have an answer to the original thread's question, just wanted to point out that it was ridiculously weird during season 3, that the minor characters had bigger, more interesting dating storylines than the main character.

reply

I don't understand that concept. If people are born gay, how can they live a portion of their lives not knowing that they're gay?

reply

It's not about not knowing. It's about not admitting.

reply

AMEN to that! Well said!

reply

Because the whole world is telling them every day that they should be straight, and up until about 15 years ago, there were no depictions of gay relationships in the media, so until people would stumble into it, most gay people simply had no idea why they didn't seem to have "normal" feelings for the opposite sex. Not to mention, the very occasional depiction of a gay person in the media before the 1970s (and many thereafter) showed them as mentally ill, and the happy resolution to the show was often a straight relationship. How is someone who knows she (or he) isn't mentally ill supposed to identify with the "sick" gay people in things like They Only Kill Their Masters?

There were gay characters before Ellen, who were not negative: there was Jody on Soap, whose weirdness was essentially normal, because he was weird and gay among many straight and sometimes weirder people, which is probably why the show got away with it; there was also a single episode of The Mary Tyler Moore Show, and the occasional "Archie is homophobic, too," bit on All in the Family, but no gay love stories, really, until Ellen, in 1997. There were also movies, like Desert Hearts, or Lianna, but they were independent films, not major studio pictures, or primetime TV shows.

And, then, there is the fact that sex is still sex. A lot of gay people are perfectly capable of an opposite sex hook-up-- your favorite flavor of ice cream might be chocolate, but butter pecan is still pretty good-- but being gay is about who you fall in love with. Also, there are people who could probably fairly be called "bisexual," but really are closer to one end of a continuum, or the other. People who are closer to the gay end may not be really happy in a long-term straight relationship, even though they may have dated straight people, and enjoyed it.

Even if you are gay, you still have to know it exists: think about being a really small child, three or four, with no awareness of sexuality, and maybe even still unaware of "where babies come from." You might be straight, but you don't know it yet, because you don't even know about sex yet.

I'm guessing you are pretty young, and it's hard for you to imaging a world where someone could reach young adulthood (say, 18), and have never heard the word "homosexual," but that was America before about 1968.

reply

Ellen Morgan was always a lesbian, but she was in denial about it her entire life.

Like any homosexual man or woman in this world, they are either very insecure, neurotic, or unsure-of-themselves that they are not aware of their true sexual orientation or are in denial of it most of their lives until they have a self-realization of it in their 20s, 30s, 40s, or even 50s.

It's unusual and uncommon for a gay person to be unsure or in denial most of their lives, but it does happen out there in real life.

reply

ive been watching the first few seasons recently, and ellen (the character) always looked awkward dating men, and talking about men, she always just seemed not to be into them at all, so i wud say yea, shes always kinda known she was gay a little, b4 finally realising

hey, yoda needs to give some better advice, or yoda needs to shut the *beep* up

reply

Ellen Morgan, like Ellen Degeneres,did what she thought society demanded; pursued heterosexual relationships, but they never felt right. The characters coming out was extremely logical, regardless of the reality of Ellen Degeneres. The character seemed awkward in most social occasions, especially in her relationships and felt like an outsider. This came more to the fore in Season 3, then was ramped up in Season 4, in preparation for the coming out. When you watch the series as a whole, the character arc makes sense; it's doesn't seem like a ratings stunt.

Many of my gay friends and co-workers went through periods like this, attempting to fit in to the roles that society placed on them, but never feeling comfortable. When they became comfortable with their real selves and started living the truth, their lives blossomed.

reply

ELLEN MORGAN WAS ALWAYS GAY!

You don't just decide to change from straight to gay in the middle of your thirties. It's something that was either there from the beginning or not. It's not a choice. It also doesn't matter that she dated men in the early seasons. It doesn't matter who you date or have sex with, that does not determine your sexuality. Two men or two women could have sex together and still be straight just like a man and a woman could have sex together and both of them still be gay. It's a matter of who you are attracted to. If you are a man and attracted to and/or desire only men then you are gay and vice versa for women. It's not a matter or the action but the intent/desire behind it.

Ellen Morgan was always gay, she was just afraid to come out of the closet and admit it to herself.

reply

[deleted]

Ellen was straight. Many of you are looking at this from the perspective that the character Ellen was a real person, but don't confuse the character with the actor.

When Ellen Degeneres started that show she was just another comedian, she hadn't taken off yet. The reason the studio went with her wasn't just because of her talent (which was abundant) but because giving sitcoms to stand up comics had become the rage after Sienfeld. While Degeneres stood out, the format of the show follows the generic sitcom formula of the time. (Much like today)

So what we have is the immature sex lives of a bunch of 20/30 somethings living in the city. The studio had neither the guts or intention to make the character gay. If she appeared awkward, it's because the character was awkward.

Once the show established itself and Degeneres's stardom began to take off things changed. The show gained a loyal fan base and Degeneres now wielded more influence. The audience knew Degenerce was gay and it was decided to chance officially changing the character Ellen as well. (It had been unofficially changed already via innuendo)

reply

Actually, the show got a reboot after the first season, and DeGeneres had a lot more creative control. I would say that you are right, that in the first season, the one with Maggie Wheeler, when DeGeneres had long hair and wore make-up, she was written as an entirely straight woman, with no undertones of something not quite fitting, and DeGeneres plays her as straight, and does it just fine.

After the reboot, in the second season, DeGeneres had more creative control, and this is when the character is still dating men, but there is a definite change in her behavior, in her body language and vocal tone-- as an actress, DeGeneres is playing "uncomfortable," and I think whether the writers are on board or not, DeGeneres is playing the character as struggling with her sexual identity.

By the third season, she has stopped dating men, and the gay male character, Peter, has been introduced, as a way of testing the waters for audience and advertiser reaction to a gay character, I assume. In the fourth season, there are all kinds of teasers, but by then, the show had survived an initial decision to cancel it, so the decision involved ratings, to an extent. If DeGeneres had not decided the character would eventually come out, there would not have been a fifth season, and probably not even a fourth season.

reply

Um, she probably was always gay, but that doesn't necessarily mean she was aware of it. I think that's more what they are meaning when they ask "Was she always gay?" More like "Was she aware she was gay, was she out to anyone in real life?"

I'm 30 and it's only been in the past 6 months that I finally realized "Holy *beep* the reason I end up in terrible relationships with guys that crash and burn is because I'm gay... WHOA I'M GAY!" I actually said that to myself one day. It ended 15 years of feeling inept, awkward and unsure of myself.

reply

This is what broke the show in my opinion. Originally Ellen was like Seinfeld but featuring a female lead. Her character was straight and dated men. Around the 4th season DeGeneres came out to her cast mates and friends and the show was reworked to lead up to the character coming out near the end of the season. Ellen went public as a lesbian around the same time.

I've always thought Ellen was hilarious, and incidentally her intelligence and humor is very attractive. Unfortunately the sitcom wasn't conceived as a show about a gay woman trying to find love, and her place in the world. That's not a bad concept for a show, but it wasn't what made this show funny.

reply

Yeah, she was always gay. She was presumably "in the closet" as they say. Namely, felt pressured to live a lie, or was not really able to face the truth within herself.

reply

No and I agree with the one post this is what killed the show. I understand Ellen wanted to play a gay character in her show but it back fired for a few reasons.

reply