MovieChat Forums > Philadelphia (1994) Discussion > Why did Denzel almost go back to Tom Han...

Why did Denzel almost go back to Tom Hanks apt?


After Denzel watches Tom Hanks act out that opera in the apartment, he leaves and then he almost goes back in. I didn't get this scene. Why did Denzel almost go back into Tom Hanks apartment?

reply

I think it was an instinct of compassion. When he hears Beckett start the music again, he realizes on some level that here is a man who is soon to be robbed of the greatest gift. The aria itself (one of my personal favorites - you should also check out "Nemico della patria" from the same opera) is about how even in the midst of suffering, love makes of our earth a heaven.

reply

IMO, two reasons:

1) To apologize for his earlier statement after Andrew told him he survived his first "gay party" (Joe's reply was stern and rather harsh)

2) To tell Andrew he understood his absolute passion for the opera music

reply

Exactly right to both of you, who replied. As Andrew performed the aria, you could see that Joe went through a dramatic conversion of the soul. He saw at last, not a gay man, not a man with AIDS, but simply a man who loved life and didn't want to leave it. And he decided not to because he didn't want to interrupt Andrew's moment. He heard him starting the music again.

reply


I thought he went back to finish what he originally came to do (prepare Andy for the trial in the morning)since he had left like a bat out of hell after hearing Andy's explanation of the opera.
==============================
He lifts me clear to the sky, you know he taught me to fly.

reply

Exactly! The whole point of the lawyer's coming over was to prepare his witness/plaintiff for his testimony the next day. Time was precious. Any real lawyer would have shut off the damn stereo and squeezed in some crucial witness-prep time.

reply

It's funny how differently people interpret the scene. I saw it as Denzel being shown this private, vulnerable moment of passion from a man about to die... It was intense, there witnessing such an emotional moment, more than he was bargaining for that night. Too close for comfort, crossing a line in their 'relationship' that hadn't been crossed before. I think it was too intense for Denzel's character...like seeing something you're not supposed to see...so he leaves to save Tom's dignity and just spare himself from the awkwardness and intensity of the moment. So he hurries out, which, I don't know, seemed an 'ouch' for me on Tom's behalf, since he had just shared this exposing vulnerable moment with another human being. And Denzel just leaves, wipes his hands of it.

So he's glad to be out of there...but then he hears the music again. And has a twinge of conscience. Now poor Tom is in there having that emotional moment still, but all by himself this time, since Denzel wouldn't share it with him. So he almost goes back in....but then decides just to leave it alone and not disturb him again.

But obviously the whole experience affected Denzel, even if in an uncomfortable, under his skin kind of way.

...I've seen different people comment on this scene but a lot of times, Denzel's character's "Wow this is awkward and too much for me right now" seems to get left out. But it just screamed that to me! It was too much for him, and too intense, sharing something that personal with Tom.. He's like "oookay this just took a turn for the really weird, I'm going to leave now." But like I mentioned...it got under his skin, since it was still in his head when he went home to embrace his loved ones.

reply

[deleted]

Glad this question was asked I was wondering the same thing.

reply

Miller was going through his spiritual change. Never again could he be his old self after that night as it was meant to be. Andrew was having a unique moment with him and Miller thought he could handle it but alas he couldn't.

He didn't know how to properly react so he ran out and tried to save his manly pride. He was also kind of scared and freaked out by Andrew. He got really close to him and he never figured he would have done so. Once the music hit again he wanted to go back in and get over it but he realized he couldn't. He wanted to be there but his manly pride said no.

However he had a new respect and place for Beckett after that. He became truly dedicated to winning the case and his homophobia was gone. He realized he had a good ally with not much time left and it hurt him. He went home and got close to his family.

reply