MovieChat Forums > Poison Ivy (1992) Discussion > An excellent, underrated film ruined by ...

An excellent, underrated film ruined by two pathetic sequels


I first saw this moody, atmospheric film on cable in 1993, being 15 at the time, I wasn't really into erotic flicks like this, but since Drew Barrymore was in it, I decided to stay up and watch it. Time completely slipped away from me while I watched it. I was transfixed. The movie had everything: an excellent cast, beautiful cinematography and look to it, superb acting and a brilliant storyline. I recorded the last half hour of the film because I enjoyed it so much, and purchased a VHS copy a year later. In 2000, I bought the DVD and thanks to the internet, heard about the two sequels. My expectations were pretty small (how could you follow up a film like this without completely ripping it off?). Poison Ivy II was absoloutly terrible. Everything that made the original great was gone. There is absoloutly nothing to it. Alyssa Milano's character is never completely 'obsessed' with Ivy, if she was, she would have gone to horrible lengths to be like her, which meant doing all things Ivy did, not just the sleeping around and skanky dressing, but the deception and even murder as well. Poison Ivy III was awful, you know those late night soft-core porn films with absoloutly horrendous acting and plot lines, well this could easily be considered one of them. The whole film was forced, the acting was putrid, and it seemed as if it only existed for the value of sex.

Nobody seems to acknowledge the original Poison Ivy today; it never got the attention it deserved. Perhaps this is because of the marketing, maybe because Drew Barrymore wasn’t a huge star in 1992, maybe because people just didn’t want to see an erotic film like this – maybe they were all busy with Basic Instinct. It’s certainly hasn’t remained notorious all these years on (in the vein of other erotic flicks like Basic Instinct, Fatal Attraction or Blue Velvet)…its pretty much a forgotten, late-night thriller film. Why didn’t this become huge, or even a cult classic? It certainly had the potential. Suppose it’s too late now to be revitalized. Least I can recognize this is an excellent movie without being ashamed at the same time. It’s not really like those other soft-core porn films, it has something about it.

reply

I COMPLETELY agree with everything you said!
...except one thing which you didnt mention and im not sure if you do agree, but i thought Alyssa's acting in the second was good and was one of the things that kept me from turning it off...
BUT! the 1st is just fantastic. One of my favourite movies of all time and the acting was great! Such an underrated movie and should have got the attention it deserved... shame its too late now :(

Bishop O'Hara: You took a vow of hospitality for all in need.
Rev. Mother: I lied.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

The second film was so boring compared to the original, it wasn't interesting, it was just plain weird.

Siri

Don't Make Me Have to Release the Flying Monkeys!


reply

Yes it was a surprisingly decent film, the 2nd was just boring not Superman Returns boring but boring, I kinda enjoyed III it's more like a Remake then a Sequel really.

And the so called 4th film is hilarious.

reply

WOW, I AGREE WITH EVERY WORD YOU SAID! The movie was so great, but you never hear about it. I'm 16 so the movie actually came out the year I was born. The only reason I bought Poison Ivy on DVD is because I'm Leonardo DiCaprio's biggest fan, and he is actually an extra in this (a scene at school where the bell rings and kids run by the camera). So I just felt obligated to own it, but when I actually watched the movie, I fell in love with it.

So I really wasn't expecting much from the sequels but I gave them a try anyway. 2 was horrendous. Alyssa Milano is a terrible actress and the entire film was unrealistic and stupid. 3 was a series of sex scenes. The only parts where it wasn't sex was when the characters needed to walk to a different room and then proceed to have sex. It was ridiculous. And Jamie whatever is an awful actress. I wish they never made the sequels

reply

I don't think it's too late for a film like this to be revitalised. In fact, I think it already has achieved somewhat of a cult status. Thanks to internet blogs like Tumblr, hipster girls and (to a lesser extent) boys absolutely adore movies like Poison Ivy, with the skanky, revealing early 90s Drew Barrymore and you will find that they blog about it frequently. It's just difficult to come across these particular posts because a lot of tags relate to the Poison Ivy DC character from Batman which is annoying.

Nonetheless, it definitely has garnered some kind of a cult reputation thanks to video, cable and the internet. It is a very hypnotising film and I always watch it when it's on television.

reply

I actually didnt think the sequels were too bad.

reply