MovieChat Forums > Aladdin (1992) Discussion > Why Isn't Disney Learning More Lessons F...

Why Isn't Disney Learning More Lessons From Aladdin?


At the time of its release, this was he biggest animated film of all time, and it's still the last non-Pixar Disney film to top the box-office chart for its respective year.

Now, I must say, this isn't one of my personal favourite Disney animated films. It's a little too cartoonish and slapdash for my tastes, at times, although I do appreciate Robin Williams as the Genie.

BUT what Disney *SHOULD* be learning from this film's PHENOMENAL success, is that boys like Disney films too, boys want protagonists they can root for and identify with, and the rags-to-riches/marry a princess fantasy applies to boys just as much as it applies to girls (and yet, Disney keeps pandering to the self-indulgent fantasies of women with Cinderella and Pretty Woman, and such CRAP, ignoring the FACT that many men are poor and working-class too; IN FACT, it's a FACT that MORE MEN are homeless than women, but we never talk about that, do we? *sigh* 🙄)

Stop pandering to would-be princesses, and give us GUYS some wish-fulfilment fantasies (and I'm talking about WORKING-CLASS GUYS here; not spoiled rich boys, who always get *their* twisted Prince Charming to the rescue BULLSHIT and frankly MISOGYNIST fantasies catered to). Have some more animated classics where the poor but plucky working-class lad gets to woe the spoiled but beautiful princess, assuming that's 'allowed' in this era. *sigh* 🙄🤦‍♂️

reply


It's a little too cartoonish and slapdash for my tastes, at times..


Which is everything I like about this. This is pure fantasy. Reality need not apply.

I would say Aladdin and Beauty and the Beast are my two favorite Disney animated films.

reply

Aladdin is the greatest Disney film ever.
Also because it's everybody's fantasy, boys and girls both have heroes they can identify with.

reply

OMFG, a grown man is whining that Disney isn't making kiddie films just for him!!!

reply

I'm a grown-up straight guy and I liked "Cinderella". I can identify with any human with an interesting story, including a woman. A protagonist doesn't have to be just like me. Imagine that!

reply