MovieChat Forums > Aladdin (1992) Discussion > Disney needs to release the extra 16 hou...

Disney needs to release the extra 16 hours of recordings


Apparently Disney has 16 hours of unreleased footage of Robin Williams doing funny Genie stuff. Disney needs to release this, even if it has swearing etc! I would pay money to buy a DVD set of this.

reply

No. Williams' schtick unfortunately started to wear on people about ten years ago. He's definitely funny and greatly contributed to film, but he peaked a long time ago.

reply

Define "a long time ago." Even if I believed that he was past his prime when he passed away, this move came out at the height of his popularity. I would imagine that it was hilarious and prime material, and even if it was just okay I would want to give it a listen.

reply

He peaked at Good Will Hunting in terms of creatively.
I doubt there's anything besides a few minutes of funny jokes in that 16 hrs. It's probably very annoying.

reply

I read the Aladdin script and was surprised because it describes the genie as a "Robin Williams type character", which means it was before he was cast. The script is almost identical to the final movie which means there wasn't that much ad libbing. I think the studio just made it up to promote the movie as hip, on the fly. Yes, the man was funny and cutting edge in the 70s, 80s and part of the 90s in terms of delivery. I won't deny him that.

reply

[deleted]

Which script are you referring to? Is it online?

reply

I worked at a Disney store back in 1992. Someone had a printed copy-I don't know if its online, but I remember' The "Robin Williams type actor" notation in the script

reply

So you don't have it now?

reply

Nope, but it was published, purchased piece so it must exist somewhere

reply

Okay, it's because I've looked for the official Aladdin script a few times online and haven't found it. The closest I got was a draft from around early 1991.

reply

This was definitely a draft before the final movie because there were some slight changes in it so it was probably around 1990 or 1991. This is in LA. There are quite a few script stores in LA-maybe try calling a few of them. I have a Beauty and the Beast script and a Lion King script from a place in Hollywood-not sure if its still there

reply

They have released outtakes of him recording lines but it would be a lot and will they show him recording the lines and just that. But it is not really big surpise that he improvised that much

reply

The Blu-ray Diamond Edition includes some of Williams' ad-libs/outtakes, but only the audio, with storyboard reels drawn by Eric Goldberg, who'd created/animated Genie.



.

reply

Well you have to talk to Robin Williams family about that. Disney can't release anything that has him on it without their permission.

reply

Where did you read from? I wasn't aware that Williams's family owned the copyrights to the Genie in this film.


EDIT: Apparently, you're right.

A former Disney executive revealed that enough of the actor's lines from the original 1991 recording sessions wound up on the cutting-room floor for the company to use them and make a fourth installment of the “Aladdin” franchise, according to the Times of London.

Unfortunately, Disney had to ditch the plans when they discovered Williams' will prevents them from using his name, taped performances or voice recordings for 25 years after his death.

http://nypost.com/2015/11/08/robin-williams-will-prevents-use-of-outtakes-for-aladdin-sequel/





What we do in life, echoes in eternity.

reply

Where did you read from? I wasn't aware that Williams's family owned the copyrights to the Genie in this film.

Disney owns the copyrights of the Genie character but they don't own Robin Williams.

Everything about Robin Williams his likeness, voice, etc belongs to his family. They call it personality rights. You just can't use someones voice, image, or anything that is part of a persons identity without their or if they have passed away their families permission. Especially if your going to use it to sell something. Thats grounds for an immediate lawsuit if you violate it.

reply

Where did you read from? I wasn't aware that Williams's family owned the copyrights to the Genie in this film.


They don't own Genie but they own his voice. Since his voice is on the recording, his family owns the rights to his specific recordings

It's like How Lifetime did a Whitney Houston biopic but couldn't use Whitney's recordings but were able to use her songs being re-sung by Deborah Cox

Whitney didn't write her songs, so her estate doesn't own the lyrics or instrumental tracks. But her estate owns the rights to her specific recordings of the songs because her voice is on them.

So Whitney's estate can't stop others from re-making her songs but they can stop people from using her specific recording of her songs. Her voice, Houston Estate's property


Same goes for Robin Williams. His voice is his estate's property

reply

I think it sound exhausting. Not even the hard-core Robin Williams fans would take it. Even they would agree Williams was funny in small doses.

Besides, apart from being a memory, would anyone find it that great? He was a legend but he lost his creative mojo somewhere around 1995.

reply