MovieChat Forums > My Girl (1991) Discussion > Are people serious about crying in this?...

Are people serious about crying in this? *spoilers*


I'm sorry I couldn't help but laugh at the bee scene. Not that I'm heartless or sick, but this scene was just laughable. Okay first we have Macaulay Culkin messing with a bee hive knowing he was allergic. Than of course the dramatic effect how he swats at the air like he's blind and just stands there and lets the bees feast on him like flies on a dead animal. Of course that's not bad enough than the director shows his glasses slowly falling in the leaves? What did the bees eat the rest of him?

reply

We don't know he knowingly had a bee allergy otherwise he wouldn't have messed with the hive in the first place. You CAN be allergic to something and not know it until the reaction sets in you know...and my grandmother has made it to 90 years old, never been stung so it ain't that hard to believe an 11 year old could to a point either.

reply

And they certainly never make a point of mentioning his allergies being a huge issue or anything...

When you're 17 a cow can seem dangerous and forbidden...am I alone here?

reply

Childhood Friend of mine died when he was in his 40s getting stung. Left behind two kids and a wife. What a shock.

reply

I'm guessing he didn't run because he was already reacting to the bee stings.

reply

[deleted]

The part that always gets me is when she sees him at the funeral and starts talking like he's alive and she runs off and goes to her teacher.

reply

The dad said to Vada that he was ALLERGIC to bees... So no the bees did not "eat the rest of him". Throughout the movie it's known that Thomas J. had a lot of allergies. This movie is hardly laughable! You have to be pretty cold hearted to find the end of this movie funny... The parts that get me to tears is the funeral scene and the very end when she reads her poem to the class. First movie to ever make me cry

reply

They were wasps (or hornets) not bees. Also, they *stung* him (the other end); they didn't 'eat', or bite him.
He jolted them out of their nest and they defended their home, attacking him. It's highly probable his allergic reaction quickly began to subdue him; he'd be unable to think properly and his reflexes would suffer.

It IS cold to think the loss of a friend is funny, even if the movie handled it in a clumsy way.

reply

The actual bee attack scene isn't that sad. Its the scenes afterward with Vada and his parents mourning his death that really get to people.

reply

The bee scene, mild as it was traumatized me since I'm afraid of bees. I might try watching this when it's on again tonight but still that part about the bees is creepy, just the fact that with allergies you might never know you have them and then a few stings can kill you. Horrifying way to die.

reply

The whole scene is still laughable. I'm not cold hearted, it's just Culkin's acting that makes it funny. He doesn't even sound convincing in the scene. It's almost as bad as when he dies in The Good Son.

reply

He was like ten years old. And I think it's all a matter of opinion. Personally I thought it was extremely sad.

reply

It's not laughable. It's a small kid getting stung by hundreds of bees, he reacted exactly how any small kid would when they're frightened. I think he played the scene really well.
The bit that gets me is when Vada goes "Where's his glasses? He needs his glasses!" - has me in tears every time

Four legs good, Two legs bad

reply

Are you kidding?

His scream as he's falling off the cliff in "The Good Son" gives me chills!

It's different from his "Home Alone" screams, because those are meant to be humorous.

His scream in TGS is sheer terror.

-Amanda

"She will remember your heart when men are fairy tales in storybooks written by rabbits"

reply

Wow you obviously have bad taste...and yes, you are cold-hearted....everyone else thinks so.

reply

I bet you wouldn't find it "laughable" if something like this really happened to someone you loved.

And saying you're not heartless or sick, that's called denial.

reply

To be fair to the original poster, he/she was not trying to be cold or heartless. They were just expressing an opinion that Thomas J's actual death scene was poorly executed and had some bad acting. I don't really agree, but it's a valid opinion to have.

The scenes after that are the ones that are tough to watch. If you get to the part where Vada runs away from her teacher without welling up, then you've developed a pretty strong resistance to sad movies. I don't cry a lot at films, but this one is as emotional as it can be. That was an impressive acting job that Anna did in the final act of the film.

reply

Granted Thomas probably did not know he was allergic, but really I think the sadder scene was the description of the mother's death. The whole movie was framed around it and it made sense, in context. The boy's death however seemed a bit more Hays Code required. The young friends have their first kiss, then suddenly the boy has to go. Otherwise, ya know, menstruation, young hormones; they might have had to deal with the issue of sex between minors, maybe even some seriously underage procreation. Instead the writers nip that idea right in the bud and kill the little blond boy.

Honestly, I think it would be a great deal more moving if the relationship just failed because they realized they were not ready for it, maybe giving the kids in the audience the fully justified explanation that they might be too young and there are reasons they should not have sex yet, not simply that God will murder you if you get too close to scoring.

reply

[deleted]

Whoa, how did you equate a first kiss at 11 years old to sex between minors and being killed off to avoid it? Yeah in a sense the writers "killed" him since they wrote the story, but much like in real life, he tragically died an untimely death due to a freak accident, it had nothing to do with what may or may not have happened between him and Vada.

I guess maybe it is different for boys (and maybe girls these days too...geeze I sound old, I promise I'm not that old) but a first peck on the lips for an 11 year old girl does not mean her next step would have been jumping in the sack. A first kiss between two best friends is about as innocent in the sex/love world as one can get...a kiss that clearly freaked them both out.

I'm thinking you missed the point of this movie. Both Vada and her dad were living life in the shadow of death...Harry because he was surrounded by it and was absorbing the grief of his clients, and his daughter because she was afraid of death...first her mother and then constantly seeing dead people brought to her house. It's just as Thomas Jay said, she's afraid of death so she is constantly worried she's dying...but worrying about dying is scarier than actually dying, because if she did and become one of them, she would fear them no longer.

The irony is that the thing that is probably a kids worst unrecognized nightmare, her best friend dying, is the things that actually helped her face death and to become less afraid of it. This was a coming of age story about life and death, it had NOTHING to do with hormones and teenage (or in this case child) sex.

reply

They. were. not. bees.

They. were. WASPS.

A wasp is not a type of bee.

reply

I don't really see anything funny about the death of a child. And in the context of the film it was really sad for Vada and Thomas to lose each other. Very normal for this movie to bring some people to tears. Very abnormal not to even understand this normal reaction in other, more sensitive people.

reply

They were absolutely Bees, they say it numerous times in the film...

reply

[deleted]

I'm allergic to bees, wasps and hornets and I didn't know until 3 years ago. Luckily I only stepped on a bee so i was stung in the foot and the reaction wasn't too bad but still my foot and leg were swollen up to my knee (i couldn't walk on it properly for 2 weeks) and if i had been stung anywhere near any vital organs i would have had to be rushed to the hospital. Sometimes you just don't know. So, for me that scene always makes me sad because it scares me that it could happen to me if i ran into a group of bees. But on the other hand everyone has different levels of sensitivity and people are affected by different things in different ways. So it may not have been very sad for you but it sure gets me every time.

reply

Bumping this to state, I don't want to sound heartless it's not the fact he died by the bees that made it laughable it's how it was directed and Culkin's acting. His scream in TGS is the best part, that little bastard had it coming, and no one with half a brain can deny his acting performance in that movie was pure awful.

reply

Sorry to say I don't believe you because people who are cold or heartless ALWAYS use that excuse. Its like racist/homophobic people who defend themselves by stating they are not racist/homophobic. If you dont want to come across as such a person, DO NOT say you are NOT such a person, its just laughable. I found that scene and the scene after that some of the saddest movie scenes ever. I wonder if something like this happened to someone you loved, would you still be laughing?

reply

[deleted]

The fact that you would equate and reaction to death in a movie with a reaction to the death of a loved one says more about you then the OP did about the poster.

reply