MovieChat Forums > Grand Canyon (1992) Discussion > White upper-class guilt trip, but at lea...

White upper-class guilt trip, but at least the filmmakers are aware


I don't mean the title of this thread to be inflammatory, because I'm actually going to compliment the film.

It clearly is made from the perspective of privileged upper-middle to upper-class white people but what I liked about the film was that the filmmakers were clearly under no illusions that they were coming from a sheltered position, and throughout the film several observations are made, usually by the black characters, particularly Glover's, about how naïve, albeit well-meaning the white characters, particularly Kline's, are.

Whilst I was watching the film I remember feeling irritated that Kline had been so presumptuous as to think Glover and Alfre Woodard's characters would be a great match, effectively because they were both black, and so was delighted by the scene where these two characters get together and Glover comments, in good-humour, that they must be the only black people Kline knew.

The film also portrays the prejudice experienced by Alfre's son in the film in a low-key and non-sensationalist way that gets across the everyday experience of a black teen moving to a predominantly white, and thus, mistrustful, neighbourhood. The humiliations 'Otis' undergoes are raw and powerful but not overdone, and I thought that demonstrated admirable sensitivity and understanding on Kasdan's part.

Of course, no upper-middle-class white guy is going to know what it's like to be a black kid in LA, but at least Kasdan doesn't try to pretend otherwise, and what he does depict seems credible and refreshingly free of either sanctimony or gross stereotype.

reply

Yeah, that's it... partly only. I have watched this movie today again after many years, and what amazes me is that is a WASP view of an unbalanced, nearly distopic world. I have a problem with Kline character, who only does right nearly by chance and pushed by his wife, and I have a problem with the McDonnell one, who is so obsessed of being 10 years younger again (there is an amazing detail I realized this time: when she finds the baby, all the Roberto's baby stuff is there: she never gave it to anyone, not even the bath).

But after all it is all about Kline trying to be a better person, trying to feel humble (his dream sequence is all about social class and social aspirations) and we accepting him for what he is. He didn't change much in the fate of things, but he tried, unlike the Steve Martin's character, who soon is overwhelmed when confronted by change.

What it is still amazing is not only how it predates all the 90s crisis and revolts, but nowadays society, again, in a nearly distopic manner (the Glover's sister starts to live better when she is in a rich neighbourhood, as where you live is what decides on what you are going to be in your life... not as is, it is just is). And, of course, the skills of the Kasdans with the narrative and the characters, the composition of scenes, the actor's work, single amazing scenes like the car driving lesson, every single detail of a shot giving you information of the motivations... It takes a lot from Altman and Alan Rudolph (characters and conversations are *very* Rudolph) and then it influences later similar movies as The Ice Storm and Magnolia.

And check the helicopter serving as an all-seeing eye. Just like in "Short cuts".

God, how I love this movie.

reply