MovieChat Forums > The Fisher King (1991) Discussion > Really promising film until Robin Willia...

Really promising film until Robin Williams showed up


Which is ironic, because I watched this in part because Williams died recently, and he was Oscar-nominated for this. But I also have loved certain Terry Gilliam films (12 Monkeys, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, and most of all Brazil), so I was hoping this was another one of his good ones.

And for the first few minutes, it seemed like it really was. Bridges was doing an amazing job as the shock jock, the cinematography was cool, the whole thing seemed to be really clicking, along the lines of Oliver Stone's Talk Radio but even better.

My appreciation for the film dipped slightly for the first few minutes after the "three years later". Also ironic, since Mercedes Ruehl won an Oscar for this, but her character wasn't doing it for me. Still, it was holding my attention; then "Parry" showed up as a trashcan knight with his other homeless bozos, and I just completely lost interest. I kept watching, but it never really picked up after that, other than a few nice moments like the waltz in the train station, or the "singing telegram" scene.

--------
Daily single-tweet movie reviews: https://twitter.com/SlackerInc

reply

I disagree but do see where your coming from. I have nitpicks about the scene where we meet Parry.

The scene where Jack is attempting suicide and those kids come is very bi polar in the mood. I dont know if its the way Terry Gilliam directed it but it seemed to me that the scene is out of place in regards to the rest of the movie.

Now i really do love Robin and will always think of him in the living but there's something about his portrayal as Parry that doesnt sit right with me. I can't point out what though.

If theres one part of this movie i dont care for its the part where Parry is 'working' in the video store and then Lydia comes in. Enterntaining yes, but kind of annoying.

I'M SORRY I'D LISTEN TO YOU IF YOU WERENT WRONG.-Robin Williams, Awakenings

reply

Presumably you knew Williams was featured prominently in the film, so why did you even attempt to watch it if you found him so lacking as a performer? Your comments reek of disingenuousness and deliberate provocation. Might be worthwhile to check out the cast list before buying your popcorn and settling in for a two-hour disappoint-fest.

 Some movies are released; others sneak out. 

reply

Seems like you didn't read my OP, which I assure you was sincere:

I watched this in part because Williams died recently, and he was Oscar-nominated for this.


I would add that I doubt his character's storyline would have been better with another actor in the role. I just don't like that part of the script.

--------
Daily single-tweet movie reviews: https://twitter.com/SlackerInc

reply

Wow, fantastic discussion all.

I have loved this film since it had a limited release way back then.

May I try to add an idea?

Perry is nuts from what he has experienced, and must hide from the world.

Maybe this makes him rather cagey to understand?

(Believe me, I know people like this, some of whom did not survive that experience).

reply

I get that was the idea, but his character was so grating on my nerves.

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply

How so?

reply

That's a hard question to answer if he doesn't rub you the wrong way. Just too manic, or something.

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply

That's a hard question to answer if he doesn't rub you the wrong way. Just too manic, or something.


Intriguing... (and honestly stated).

Isn't that simply Robin Williams' go-to persona?

This film offers more intrigue on that, for he is playing someone who is utterly crazy, from unspeakable trauma, yet with a solid context for his coping mechanism. (Believe me, it can be a real situation).

Yet, this is not the Robin Williams usual "this is just the way he is" character.

Many of us met him as Mork the Alien,which explains why he acts the way he does.

But, poor Parry...

Well, maybe you just had to be alive and in New York in the 90s for his character to make sense. Parry is coping with that time and his situation about as well as anyone could.

In any case, also bear in mind, this is a fairy tale, directed by one of that genre's masters: Terry Gilliam.

reply

I worked in Manhattan in the '90s!

Also, a couple of Gilliam's films are among my very favorites; however, he has others I'm not terribly fond of.

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply

Which Gilliam films do you like and which ones don't you like?

reply

Of the 1240 movies in my Flickchart rankings, Brazil is #11, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas is #19, 12 Monkeys is #332 (still 8/10 on IMDb), The Adventures of Baron Munchausen is #933 (5/10), Time Bandits is #937, and The Fisher King is #1082 (4/10).

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply

Something I hated is how goofy the movie gets at times, Either from dialogue or the music. Which happens when Robin shows up.

I agree the beginning was great, it was really good. it was on tv and it was so good I sat down to watch it.

The story is good and I liked the movie a lot I guess. I enjoyed watching it, but there were times that it started to get too goofy, specially the score. If there is one thing that damages movies for me is when the music doesn't match the visuals or when the music starts to get silly.

Robin was really good for most of the movie but again, there were times where the character was getting to be too much (I completely blame this on the director)

I think since the subject matter is so dark, that the director chose to make it a little bit lighthearted but for me it kind of ruined it a little bit

reply

Yeah, good points.

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply

Robin was really good for most of the movie but again, there were times where the character was getting to be too much (I completely blame this on the director)
The parts I found grating were the parts that it was obvious "Robin being Robin" and the director indulging it which at times made Parry not ring true.

reply

[deleted]

It's a matter of opinion, or maybe just of taste. I was not impressed with the beginning and I always skip it when I watch the DVD. The first time I was actually afraid this might be another boring movie about mass shooting bla bla bla. I don't even watch this stuff on the news - it has become too common and too depressing. But this movie isn't really about mass shooting, that's only the pretext. Robin Williams turns it into something entirely different, and positive. I love Robin Williams in this movie and I like all the scenes with the homeless. I usually skip the Jeff Bridges and Mercedes Ruehl scenes when I watch the DVD, because I find them really boring. But that's the beauty of art, everybody relates to it differently. As long as you found something that you actually liked in this movie...

reply