Jack's radio monologue


Hey! Edwin! Hey, c'mon now, I told you about these people, they only mate with their own kind, it's called yuppie inbreeding. That's why so many of them are retarded and wear the same clothes. They're not human, they don't feel love, they only negotiate *love moments*. They're evil, Edwin, they're repulsed by imperfection, horrified by the banal, everything that America stands for, everything that you and I fight for! They must be stopped before it's too late! It's us or them!
Jack lost his career over this speech but honestly, did he really say anything inaccurate or even wrong?!?

He didn't even tell Edwin to kill them (saying someone must be stopped is not the same as saying they must be killed). He was just telling it like it is. Dammit, what is the world coming to when people can't even say rude things about yuppie pigs?!?

reply

He wasn't so much canned for the rant, so much as his association with a mass murder. Put it this way - if the guy hadn't gone into the restaurant and shot people, then Jack's career would have been fine. Noone would care that he slagged off yuppies, and they'd probably love him all the more for it. But once he got linked to the shooting - however unfairly - it was game over.

reply

I don't think that the audience is necessarily meant to believe that the industry canned him. Maybe I missed that part that says he was fired or banished.
I got the impression he had so much guilt that he took a downward spiral, drinking heavily and going into hiding pretty much.
Otherwise, how could he just so easily pick up the phone later on and call his agent and immediately get a new radio show?

In short i don't think his downfall was entirely his employer, the industry and society, but it was a large part his own reaction to it.

One could picture a person reacting to such a tragedy but not falling into a deep depression and becoming an alcoholic. Instead, they'd do some damage control and be proactive about trying to keep their career. not just giving up.

reply

He was trying to be funny but Edwin took it the wrong way, he didn't know that Jack was joking and Edwin was disturbed. You can't blame Jack for what happened, but he was careless and something terrible happened because of it.

Jack learns throughout the movie that everybody has thoughts and feelings and hidden hurts and hidden joy, and that it's a big deal to the person it's happening to. I love these characters, especially Jack and Anne but Percy and the Red Knight are sublime too. Very quirky and lovable and one of my favourite movies.

reply

I agree. He wasn't responsible for his death. Yet, at the end of the day, meanness is still meanness. You can get away with it a lot, but you never know when it is really hurting someone. Or, is just enough to push a disturbed person over the edge. The latter is an extreme and rare case. This movie reminded me of that recent example where the radio people jokingly called a hospital asking for Kate Middleton, and the nurse on the phone got fired/in trouble for HIPAA (or the UK equivalent) violation and then killed herself. They were making sport of her. Not maliciously, but still, the joke was at her expense. Normally, healthy people can take that in stride. But again, extreme cases with someone already suffering loads of issues... And if that means 'ugh, so we have to be nice to everyone? lame' Well...yeah. Maybe it does. Even if the worst that happens is just hurting someone. Let's avoid it.

In general. Yes, I think people should avoid putting others down and promoting callousness and meanness. (to the OP). I'm a convert myself so am not trying to sound high and mighty. ;) I was raised in a family where mean-spirited, sarcastic humor (often at someone's expense) was the norm and bond-worthy. So I try to unlearn it. My younger self never would have said any of these gushy things, but what can I say? experiences have changed me over the years. (Including attending somewhere that had a mass shooting.)

I was surprisingly pleased with the overall message of this movie. Promoted being nice, reaching out and helping your fellow man, imagine that lol. And I felt bad for Jack's guilt over what happened. That would be awful. My younger self would have wretched at these themes but, not anymore. I think it's good to promote.

reply

Great post blacknyellowsquid!

reply

It doesn't HURT to not be an *beep* it doesn't COST anything to have some empathy.

reply

They are even worse today.

reply