MovieChat Forums > Akira (1988) Discussion > Why is this movie not on Top 250?

Why is this movie not on Top 250?


WTF? This is one of the best Sci-fi/Animated movies I've ever seen. For the love of Tetsuo, why is this not on Top 250 and some mediocre indian films are? Anybody care to explain?

reply

Yes! It's on #250 no.w

Top 250 Foreign Movies
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls076565151/

reply

It "was".

What crap is IMDb pulling?. I watched this weird movie because it was in top 250. Now, it is not. Waste of my 2 hours of life.

WTF?.

reply

[deleted]

Because the movie doesn't make any god damn sense unless you read the manga.
And just because it is well made and hugely influential does not mean the following generations will recognise that. Its impact gets lost in time.

The name of the game is not to give the game a name.

reply

And just because it is well made and hugely influential does not mean the following generations will recognise that. Its impact gets lost in time.



The same could be said about Shawshank Redemption. If you show a viewing of this film to most of today's young generation bar a few and tell them this is currently the best rated film so far I'm sure they would beg to differ. Truly there should be no reason Akira is not lounging in the top 250.

reply

Read the sentence ommitted in your quote. Shawshank is pretty self contained and coherent compared to Akira. The reason Akira works, and was so hugely successful was its direction, stylistic choices, use of color, groundbreaking animation etc. Storywise the movie is a cluster*beep* of truly epic proportions, incomplete without the accompanying source material.


The name of the game is not to give the game a name.

reply

"And just because it is well made and hugely influential does not mean the following generations will recognise that. Its impact gets lost in time."

Yes, that's why nobody watches Casablanca anymore.


-sometimes I feel like I'm on everyone's ignore list 

reply

I actually agree with you. The animation is some of the best ever. But story wise the manga kills the movie by LOOOOOONG shot. If they were to do this today, they would've made Akira a long running mini series instead of a movie.

reply

The question is why it was on top250 and why is has a 8.1 rate when it is a piece of crap?

reply

You know nothing, @$$hole!

Top 250 Foreign Movies
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls076565151/

reply

[deleted]

It is now.

:)

reply

Goes in and out of the 250 spot...next time a big blockbuster comes out it will disappear for awhile again

reply

[deleted]

#247 Right now

reply