MovieChat Forums > Star Trek: The Next Generation (1987) Discussion > A question about Q's physical appearance...

A question about Q's physical appearance.


Firstly, I think John de Lancie is a wonderful actor and I love him as Q. Please don't misunderstand this as me being disrespectful to the actor.

My question...Why does Q appear as a middle-aged bloke with receding hair and a lisp?

Please don't say "Because John de Lancie plays him and the actor's not physically perfect", or similar.

(If the producers thought that actor didn't fit the role, they would have hired somebody else).

So with all Q's power, why does he appear physically the way he does?

reply

Because John de Lancie appears arrogant and obnoxious enough to pull it off.

Why are you here if you haven't seen the movie yet?

reply

I know what you mean. and I more or less agree. he should be some sort of heartthrob by logic.

I thought it was the only one who noticed the lisp. I am okay with a normal person/character having a bit of a speech impediment. but for someone who is supposed to be perfect in every way, no.

I often talk about my school on this site usually for good reason -- to make a point or something... Half of the people at my school have some sort of speech impediment/accents that hinder the correct learning of the English language.

srsly, the we only have about 15 people who speak correctly and they are all in the prek classes [imperative] and the speech teachers [also imperative]. the rest round out our cast of colorful 'teachers'. and yes, I actually teach when I am at work.

our ap's are just odd to say the least. idears and ambalances. libaries and ridikilusness.

I am convinced one dual language teacher can't even READ English. everything she does is in Spanish.


the interesting thing... I have noticed quite a few 'self righteous' people at work have a teensy bit of a lisp. like they make themselves speak that way to sound 'smarter'.

Oh God. Fortune vomits on my eiderdown once more.

reply

"srsly"

You have only 15 people that speak correctly..? Do you have any people that WRITE correctly?

reply

None of the other Q who appear in humanoid form are really supermodels either. Maybe his appearance is a physical representation of his personality.

"Now, I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." -- J. Robert Oppenheimer

reply

Amanda was flipping adorable.

but I guess, if they are supposed to be all powerful, you don't want some sort of Princess Di lady, you kind of want to be scared of the being.


Oh God. Fortune vomits on my eiderdown once more.

reply

She doesn't even realize that she's Q at first, which means her humanoid form ages naturally. That might explain why John de Lancie's Q appears middle-aged.

"Now, I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." -- J. Robert Oppenheimer

reply

And the writers forgot she was Q over on Voyager. Quinn claimed there'd been nothing new to talk about in forever, then when they had the civil war the solution was to add a new member to the continuum, even though she had been added just a few years before.

They also should have saved Olivia's appearance for DS9 and had her guest star as a Dabo girl.



reply

If you are going to project authority then you would want to appear as a middle-aged man.

I think it's the same reason a lot of young soldiers would not want say a young general leading them into combat. A young general would be more prone to making mistakes with them and costing them their lives than a general with some gray hair on his head. At the same time they wouldn't want a general who seemed to be so old that they would have to wonder if he was mentally all there.

It's very hard to be a pretty boy and project authority and gravitas.

reply

Not for nothing, but De Lancie isn't exactly the ugliest man in the world. You guys are talking about him like he's the elephant man.

RIP Gene Wilder. One of the funniest people of all time. RIP Matt Roberts. You were great.

reply

Given that Q views human beings as flawed, it only makes sense that he would present himself as an okay but not perfect-looking human with something of a lisp.

Q did for a moment show Picard and the bridge crew his real self, and if memory serves he had something like four heads and multiple arms. I'm sure to another Q that would be a beautiful sight to behold and to Q himself that would probably be the model of perfection.

De Lancie is not an unattractive man, but he doesn't quite constitute a perfect specimen.

reply

I agree, I don't think he is that bad looking.

I think if he was too good looking it would seem pretentious.
He is supposed to look like an average guy when he appears on the ship.
If he wanted to look Greek god like, he could have just been portrayed as a ball of bright light instead of a person at all.

BRING THEM TO HEAL!

reply

Thanks for agreeing with me, Nak. Definitely not horrible looking.

RIP Gene Wilder. One of the funniest people of all time. RIP Matt Roberts. You were great.

reply

The singer from Queensrÿche looked a bit like Q. 

reply

I thought John Delancy or whatever his name to s was sort of cute.
He had cute front teeth.

BRING THEM TO HEAL!

reply

Michael Jackson once looked a bit like a black man.

reply

Michal Jackson never really looked like a black man.
He looked like a black kid and possibly a black teen, but looking like a man, never.

BRING THEM TO HEAL!

reply

Say it with a picture:
http://www.shiachat.com/forum/uploads/post-10566-1126102875.jpg

reply

Yea, he looks very woman like starting in the 4th photo.

BRING THEM TO HEAL!

reply

He was great, any way he looked.

RIP Gene Wilder. One of the funniest people of all time. RIP Matt Roberts. You were great.

reply

"Definitely not horrible looking."

You can always trust people on this board to miss the point completely.

No one claimed he's 'horrible-looking' (I think this needs a hyphen, or it means he's not very good at 'the activity of looking').

Whether he's good or bad-looking is still not even close to the point (and it'd be subjective anyway).

The point is, he is FLAWED in his appearance, and if we imagine a 'perfect, divine being', I don't think ANYONE's mind would jump instantly to what Q actually looks like.

Logically thinking, Q should look 'PERFECT', maybe even glowing in a divine way. Q looks so 'common and flawed', like a regular human being. Whether you like his looks or not, is irrelevant, the point is that a SUPER OLD AND OMNIPOTENT ENTITY could look like absolutely anything, so it needs a good explanation as to WHY he chooses this particular form instead of just appearing as 'as perfect form as he can muster'.

The actor looks fine, but as an omnipotent, divine entity that chooses a material form to appear in the front of 'inferior entities', choosing THAT particular form is certainly puzzling, and needs an explanation.

My theory is that Q wants to MOCK the 'humans' at every turn, so he does this by appearing as a 'flawed, middle-aged dude' instead of 'the perfection of the human form' that he easily COULD have appeared as.

The lisp is a nice touch as well..

reply

Because, he's Q.

What John DeLancie looks like, totally fits Q's personality.

reply

"What John DeLancie looks like, totally fits Q's personality."

This is a brilliant point!

I also like to think about the end speech in Kill Bill Volume 2, where Bill talks about why and how Superman chose the 'Clark Kent' form - another very powerful being choosing to look 'flawed' (this time, nerdiness, eyeglasses, being clumsy and dressing unimaginatively).

Of course I don't think anyone really thought about this stuff when casting Q, I am sure the actor's personality and ability were the REAL reasons why Q looks like he does.

reply

[deleted]

Anybody's guess.

He chose a combination of physical traits that would evoke certain feelings in people looking at him.

It is random and he has little control over it like Doctor Who regenerations.

He needs to use someone's body when in our dimension like angels/demons do in Supernatural.

He was given this appearance by other Qs.

reply

Corbin Bersnen, gave him his appearance. Lol.

RIP Gene Wilder. One of the funniest people of all time. RIP Matt Roberts. You were great.

reply

[deleted]