MovieChat Forums > Star Trek: The Next Generation (1987) Discussion > There is no money in Starfleet, right? S...

There is no money in Starfleet, right? So why....


I seem to remember in previous episodes that they said that there is no money in Star Fleet. There might be money exchanged on other planets and among exotic races. But....
Near the end of "The Measure of a Man" Picard asks JAG Captain Phillipa Louvois, "Dinner?" to which she replies, "You buying?" He nods. She smiles then nods.
"You buying?"
Is this a phrase that they have kept just to add a rustic flavor to their lives like we say "better than sliced bread" and other absurd things that are long outdated? wtf?
Or do they use money for certain purposes and I'm mistaken?





reply

Never mind. I paused it to ask that question. In the next scene Data says, "there is a celebration on the holodeck" to Riker. So yeah, it was yet another awkward reference to the past (shout-out to the modern era) that didn't belong in the otherwise very good script.

EDIT: I also want to add that it would seem wildly inappropriate for the judge of a case that just closed to participate in a "celebration" for the defendant immediately after she closed the case.

But anyway....




reply

----says, "there is a celebration on the holodeck" to Riker.
----------

But how is a celebration a throwback to the past?

There is an episode where Beverly and Picard are in his Quarters (makes me jealous)
But one of them says to the other," penny for your thoughts".
That's a throwback one too.

I'll bet there are lots of throwback stuff that we say all the time and don't even think about😀
No world order that elevates one nation or group of people over another will succeed

reply

But how is a celebration a throwback to the past?


When they're in the holodeck they're almost always setting it for the 20th century or earlier.
I'm sure that someone might further note, "how would she even know that he wanted her to go to the holodeck anyway? Maybe he just wanted to eat with her in some other quarters on the ship."

^all of which is also valid

.....It's really just a ridiculously moronic line that shouldn't even be in the script, nor should a judge be so publicly close to someone who she just ruled in favor of




reply

I like old terminology. I still say Jiminey Cricket in anger.

RIP Gene Wilder. RIP Robert Vaughn. RIP Carrie Fisher. RIP William Christopher. 2016 is the worst!

reply

I'm sure it's just a turn of phrase, but I'm also of the belief that Star Trek can be full of s#it. Moneyless societies do not exist, and can't exist. Even in the Democratic People's Republic of North Korea, they use money.

The idea here is to present an example of a post-scarcity society, where thanks to matter-replicators and other things (like transporters) they no longer have to worry too much about everyone getting what they both want and need readily. But even in Star Trek some things can't be replicated, and some things probably are so tightly controlled by the fascist Federation state that black markets for those items come into being.

reply

Even in the Democratic People's Republic of North Korea, they use money.


It looks something like this https://smackamack.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/one-schrute-buck.jpg.

reply

Not the chorus please....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rlqCFv50csw 

reply

I remember that during one of Picard's speeches to one of the unfrozen 20th century people he said something like, "people just pursue their ambitions, and it makes them happy, and everything is fine."

It reminded me of that scene in "Jackie Brown" when Sam Jackson's character says to Bridget Fonda's character as she is smoking a blunt, "if you smoke too much of that sh-- it's gonna rob you of your ambition."
She replies, "not if your ambition is to get high and watch TV."

I've lived in L.A. for ten years, and I know that there are ffffffffffaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrr too many people who have that attitude for such a system to ever work.




reply

The no money concept becomes even more confusing in places like DS9, what do they pay Quark, Garak, etc with (Why would they go to Garak to begin with?). Further in one episode Jadzia says she owes Quark from a Tongo game to which Worf replies something like "I'm not loaning it to you" :?

reply

Interesting.
wtf indeed.



reply

Okay, it's supposed to be that if you are a member of Starfleet you don't need money.
Sort of like the US military. (If they didn't give it to you in your original issues, you don't need it)
They give you a place to live, on the ship or wherever you are stationed. You can use the replicators for food and clothes and sundry items. You go to the doctor when you are sick, for free.
What else would you need?
They probably give you some sort of "money" for like if you go on vacation to a non-federation planet for example.

Other planets that aren't part of the Federation have money. Like paying for drinks in Quark's on Deep Space Nine or pay go for suits or clothes made by Garek. Other people pass through or visit the station, they would have to pay to use the replicators.

But as for someone going to school so they could get a job to clean toilets in the train station, or someone even doing that job,
Yea right.
Like the old Gardner at Starfeet Academy or Sisko's dad owning a restaurant. Doubtful.
Like the other poster said, most people would it around and smoke pot.
I see tons of junkies everyday I come to work. Not a lot of ambition there.


No world order that elevates one nation or group of people over another will succeed

reply

I agree, Nak. Sometimes you're on top of things.

RIP Gene Wilder. RIP Robert Vaughn. RIP Carrie Fisher. RIP William Christopher. 2016 is the worst!

reply

DS9 is administered by the Federation, but is "owned" by Bajor, which isn't part of the Federation.

The adage "In for a penny, in for a pound" was another money reference used.

reply

DS9 is administered by the Federation, but is "owned" by Bajor, which isn't part of the Federation.


I'm aware of that however it does nothing for the query I raised

reply

In other words, not part of the Federation, money is a thing at DS9...especially at Quark's.

reply

I think the federation gives out credits (like money) to starfleet personnel. I remember one show, i forget which one talking about using federation credits for purchasing items...It may have been voyager or DS9...

reply

Voyager had replicator credits, but it was a rationing measure for energy conservation because resources were devoted to getting back to the alpha quadrant.

reply

I think this was the first episode of TNG - Dr Crusher was looking at fabric.

reply

Good call, Gambit. I remember that too.

RIP Gene Wilder. RIP Robert Vaughn. RIP Carrie Fisher. RIP William Christopher. 2016 is the worst!

reply

slg26; It may have been VOY pilot. Ensign Harry Kim was buying from Quark and shuffling thru coins.

reply

But the Ferengis were not part of the Federation--an exaggeration of capitalism, they lived for money (or gold-pressed latinum)--a totally Ayn Randian state. Where federation people got the money to interact with these other cultures is never explained. Bugged me.

But many cultures are finding that guaranteeing a minimum wage to all, without strings attached, to cover food and shelter, is extremely beneficial--reducing all sorts of ills and improving health and the drive to improve oneself. It's far too expensive right now, but as an item on the dream list it's going to be up there right after universal health care. There are stories about it bc Finland is experimenting now, and Ontario, Canada has as well as other places--small programs, all positive, just no money to implement it universally/permanently while men can hoard 70 billion dollars they cannot possibly spend...and we move backward in time requiring the poorest to pay the same percentage in taxes as these billionaires, falling deeper and deeper in debt.

reply

Population of Finland, 5.4 million. How quaint.

Why shouldn't everyone pay the and percentage? That seems fair.

No world order that elevates one nation or group of people over another will succeed

reply

Why shouldn't everyone pay the and percentage? That seems fair

I agree....

You Have a Hard Lip, Herbert..

Better Living Thru Chemistry

reply

Back in the series M*A*S*H, it was common for one character to as another if they could buy them a cup of coffee. In one episode, one character (Radar I think) was mad at someone else and responded to the offer with, "The coffee's free here."

reply

[deleted]

M*A*S*H is an excellent show. I have the first 8 seasons on DVD.

RIP Gene Wilder. RIP Robert Vaughn. RIP Carrie Fisher. RIP William Christopher. 2016 is the worst!

reply

MASH was the Army.......🙄🙄🤔🤔🤔
Duh.🙄🙄🙄
You eat at the mess hall for free.duh🙄🙄🙄🙄
No world order that elevates one nation or group of people over another will succeed

reply

"Buy you a cup of coffee" can mean "I will purchase a cup for you", but it is also a common idiomatic expression that just means "Let's have a cup together". I have spent my entire career in various office spaces that supply free coffee, and it's something that I've heard (and used) over and over. Ditto for "Coffee's free".

Frankly, I'm a little surprised it's caused confusion here.

reply

Yeah. Very common expression. You hear it all the time.

RIP Gene Wilder. RIP Robert Vaughn. RIP Carrie Fisher. RIP William Christopher. 2016 is the worst!

reply

yeah. they said it all the time in Dallas. and they were at home where the booze was free!



Oh God. Fortune vomits on my eiderdown once more.

reply

yeh how do they pay for space whores? *beep*

reply

"yeh how do they pay for space whores? "

Holodeck can provide anything and everything you need for free.

However, if they need to create a bartering system (for other-planetarians that use money etc.), replicator can create anything you need. Where is there any kind of problem?

Just replicator-create some Yamaha synthesizer for a musician on another planet, they'll pay you in their local currency, which you can then use to pay for any local goods or services, even the 'space whores'.

(Why specify 'space whores' anyway, and what makes them so SPACE? Aren't they just regular ones, or are you saying there are ones that float in space instead of living comfortably on planets? How about volunteer sexworkers that can't even be called 'whores'? (I know, on a capitalist-communist planet like this, that seems like a completely utopistic idea))

reply

In the pilot episode, Dr. Crusher "buys" or orders some fabric from a merchant on the planet. She says something like, "have this sent to my quarters".

The merchant has to paid something. Otherwise, what the hell is the point of him being there with all these goods he's showing off?





What evil drives the Car? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PoAD3kUmN9s

reply

Maybe she pays in kind so the merchants are probably looking "for a good time"? 

reply