MovieChat Forums > The Black Cauldron (1985) Discussion > Much better than its reputation

Much better than its reputation

posted 11 years ago by notaarebe
4 replies | jump to latest

Actually, this is not a bad film at all. I can think of countless modern Disney films that are far, far, far worse.

Even though the ending was badly mangled by editing (read about that story, which is scarier than the film itself), it's still a piece of gorgeous animation, with some of the most splendidly dark scenes in any Disney film this side of Fantasia.

The princess was very appealing, the hero was quite sympathetic, flawed but virtuous. The scenes of him wielding his sword have real power, given how much the viewer knows he's longed for this opportunity. And visually, that's one of the best magic-sword effects I've ever seen.

Sure, the Tolkien influence was rather blatant -- almost a LOTR rip-off -- but that's the fault of the author of the source material, not Disney. And yes, the quasi-Smeagol character was annoying.

But really, this is an enjoyable and involving movie, one that creates a world in which it is a pleasure to immerse oneself for a while.

I rate it quite satisfying.

And if it's ever given a proper re-edit with the removed scenes restored, it will rate even higher.

[–] 11 years ago

[deleted]

[–] notaarebe 11 years ago

Yes, Gurgi was the single worst character in the film, with his Gollum-like speech pattern. Almost single-handedly ruined the film.

But otherwise, I generally enjoyed the film, though it's definitely flawed.

[–] ZakkWyldeMyLittlePony 11 years ago

I hear ya. It's unfairly blacklisted.

"Screw you guys, I'm going home"-Eric Cartman

[–] Taran_of_Prydain 10 years ago

It's really a great film. I have watched it 3 times in the last few weeks and I admire it even more with every viewing. It's definitely one of Disney's best even with the cuts.