MovieChat Forums > Neighbours (1991) Discussion > She only did it because Paige upset her

She only did it because Paige upset her


Jack is getting more and more unlikeable by the minute. How can he justify Simone's actions like that? Especially when he comes across as very judgemental when it comes to Paige hanging out with other men

reply

Exactly! He's a prick!

🐨Have you ever?...Ever felt like this?🐷

reply

To be fair I think she's got the wool pulled over his eyes proper.

reply

She has indeed, I'm intrigued as to why...Guilt, over dumping her?

🐨Have you ever?...Ever felt like this?🐷

reply

Probably and also more naive than he sometimes appears? Wanting to believe the best of her as well?

reply

That's a good point. He is utterly naive...like he was raised in cocoon or something. I once knew a fella who was like that in RL. It was heart-breaking,as he was so lovely.

🐨Have you ever?...Ever felt like this?🐷

reply

He doesn't come off that worldly at times, and it's definitely a writing/acting choice, because his H&A character wasn't like that beyond the usual daydreamer stuff you see generally. It would be rather sad, though, in RL.

reply

I think it's the writers to be honest, maybe I'm wrong, but that's the impression I get.

It was very sad, upsets me to think about it.

🐨Have you ever?...Ever felt like this?🐷

reply

I wonder if they don't get priests? I know our local one slightly - I do voluntary work at the charity shop associated with the church but the funny thing is, all the ladies I work with aren't Catholic either. It's just one of those things. But anyway, our priest is pretty clued in to things at least on passing acquaintance, and there are times Jack just seems... not, so it very likely is the writers not getting it.

I'm sorry.

reply

I had the feeling he was being written by someone who doesn't get or doesn't like priests.

reply

It does feel like that, doesn't it? I mean, I didn't think the other priest (as you once called him, Father Carked It) was all that realistic either.

reply

Good point. He was made out to be pretty nasty.

reply

I still feel like he was slut-shaming Paige when he said "a girl like you", but yes, he really was.

reply

Completely!!

Now they have a priest/rape story going on. I definitely think there's a burnt Catholic doing the writing. I'm pretty anti-religion, but even I'm starting to cringe.

🐨Have you ever?...Ever felt like this?🐷

reply

That was the moment I became a supporter of Jack and Paige ending up together, honestly.

I think there is, like I said in another reply, I don't think the anti-church stuff is completely unintentional.

reply

Paige has kinda redeemed herself for now

🐨Have you ever?...Ever felt like this?🐷

reply

She very much has, I think. Hopefully Jack will as well. I think his being torn between being a father and a Father (couldn't resist!) would be a really good storyline in and of itself, really.

reply

YES!! I love a good pun, and a good story line too. I hope Paige is pregnant, after all this Blaze stuff and Sonya saying Jack has an excellent reputation.

Such an odd decision for the council to go against inclusivity and safe sex?!?! I hope Jack gets herpes!

🐨Have you ever?...Ever felt like this?🐷

reply

 I really feel it could be. I also feel like her saying "I'm finally moving on with my life" was pretty clear foreshadowing. Plus the rest.

It does feel weird.

I don't want him to, only because it would mean he'd have to cheat on Paige and just. No.

reply

That's true, unless he gets them from a toilet seat or being raped - haha. OK, that's too much, I just think it would give him a clearer perspective into essential abortions for rape victims and "God's will".

🐨Have you ever?...Ever felt like this?🐷

reply

It might be dark, but a male rape storyline would be really interesting, whoever it was done with. I'm sure there've been women raped on the show (it's such a go-to storyline on soaps in general but I do try to judge each story individually), so I could see that. But yes, I get it.

Either way, I hope Paige doesn't keep it from him for too long. I'm not hoping she won't hide it a little, I'm sure she would out of confusion/anger/not being sure about anything herself in the beginning, but not for too long, I hope.

reply