MovieChat Forums > Top Secret! (1984) Discussion > Things that make no sense

Things that make no sense


I get it, comedy, really funny, maybe the best comedy movie ever made.

HOWEVER..

If she knows 'a little German', then why doesn't that man help her? She knows him before meeting Nick, so why does she need NICK to help her get in the restaurant? This makes no sense. Why can't she just say 'my friend, a little German, is sitting right there, I am with him', or something? Why doesn't he offer to help, surely he must see her struggle in the entrance.

This makes no sense.

The parachute scene - of course it's funny, but it kinda takes me out of the story when things make no sense. The parachutes would get SO entangled, and they would both fall like rocks if they went so close to each other and even HUGGED in the air.

Also, aren't those parachutes opened way too soon, when they're supposed to be opened as close to the ground as possible while still high enough that you don't die? They spend ages and ages 'making love in the air' and having these dramatic conversations. I am not even going to mention the fireplace-thing, at least it's a consistent gag.

I mean, try to imagine how the parachutes would behave above what we're seeing, with every action they take - what are the chances they wouldn't get massively entangled into a mess that couldn't keep you alive when falling?

This makes no sense.

The professor digging a tunnel is funny and all, but why would he put those traffic signs in there that say something like 'New Jersey' if I remember correctly? Where did he even get those, why would he bother with them?

This makes no sense.

Just for clarification, I have laughed myself into a multi-dimensional unified entity and back, this movie is stupidly funny. But some things just do not make sense.

reply

Yeah.
I know what you mean.

"The prop room."
What in the heck kind of play or ballet would use all those airplane propellers for their production?

When Nick is singing to those girls and does some suicide attempts.
I don't think that gas stove is hooked up to anything and why would they have built a stage on railroad tracks where active trains still pass through?
That is going to be dangerous to the audience and performers.

Why did they go in there in a cow costume instead of Nazi uniforms?
Jave these guys never watched a war movie?

What kind of moms would give their baby boys names like that?
Croissant, Chocolate Mousse, Deja Vu and Latrine?

When Nigel shows them the model of the prison, what made the electric train run like that?
Where did they find an outlet to plug in the cord to make it work?

What kind of soldier would leave his boots outside and near a fence when Nick finds them?

Why is there a saloon with cowboys having a card game under water?

Yeah, this movie makes no sense at all!

reply

The professor digging a tunnel is funny and all, but why would he put those traffic signs in there that say something like 'New Jersey' if I remember correctly? Where did he even get those, why would he bother with them?
Easy: OCD


The little German couldnt help her because , er , he was banned from the retaurant for not paying his bill last time.

They opened the parsachutes early becasue , well if theres a chance to make time for a romp who wouldnt ?

reply