I think the characterization and Nimoys directing hurt her chances a lot. The cut the references to her being half Romulan from wrath of khan (the deleted scene is out there if you never saw it). This explains the conflicted emotions she has in WOK. Since they decided that she was, in fact, full Vulcan, Nimoy decided to make her act full Vulcan. So she was cold, distant and logical in this one. I think Nimoy took away all the fascinating aspects of Saavik, and left Curtis without much to work with.
So the character was super bland, and a new actress on top of it. She never stood a chance.
reply
share