MovieChat Forums > The Tripods (1984) Discussion > Would like to see these books made into ...

Would like to see these books made into movies.


I'd change a few things, like have at least ONE girl in the group. Also should the prequel come first or be added on after 1st 3 books are made?

Been quite a while since I read the books.

Can anyone help me: did the aliens kill a lot of people when they invaded? The countries that the group travel through seem quite sparsely populated where everyone is living rurally and in small communities.


I remember the old cities were off-limits but how did they keep people out?

Also there is a line about the "lands to the south", I presume Africa, South America and South Asia - Australia where we are told the Aliens "laid waste". Are we to believe all humans there were killed by the Aliens? Not by nukes as this would have polluted the whole planet and the aliens wanted a slave labour force.

reply

Non-specifically, I recall a conversation where it's mentioned that millions were killed and Will the narrator says something like 'Millions? My own village of Wherton was reckoned no small place and numbered about two hundred souls,' or similar, and goes on to mention Winchester, the nearest large town being something like fifteen thousand. (Quoting from memory). The Masters' plan seems to have been to reduce the population to the point where it's sustainable, but also largely static, to prevent free flow of seditious ideas and thus organised rebellion. Therefore a forcibly imposed pre Industrial Revolution type of society would seem the only suitable solution, in my opinion.

As to keeping people out of the 'Great Cities of the Ancients' even Will and Jack at the beginning of the first book, felt that their den in an old electricity sub-station was rather daring. Superstition and a couple of generations of elders saying 'You don't want to go there, those are evil places, where all the sickness and wickedness went on.' would have dissuaded most people from going there.

Laying waste to great areas without permanently poisoning them might have been possible with neutron weapons, and/or extremely persuasive propaganda. If the areas mentioned were also heavily patrolled as soon as it was safe, and any intruders killed or captured, that would give rise to local 'ghost stories' and taboos. It's also implied that one of the Masters' Cities came close to being nuked before the Earth was totally subjugated, by a nuke launched from a SSBN.

Just my thoughts, hope it helps!

Whit sad old loser'd be thick enough to don thon get-up?

reply

@Carlzere

Thanks for your post. Forgot that the aliens were supposed to have killed millions, yuk. What a horrible thought.

reply

SPOILERS>SPOILERS>>>SPOILERS>>>>
In the prequel novel, When The Tripods Came, it was made more obvious that the Masters had applied the old 'Divide and Conquer' routine, by sneakily influencing susceptible types to love and revere the Tripods, which weren't known to be under the control of another race. Then, in a move of great tactical acumen, but hideous hypocrisy, caused the controlled and mainly temporarily Capped humans to set about capturing and forcing the resistant humans to be Capped too.

Free humans no likee this idea, so start fighting back. However, command and control of weapons and equipment now being divided between Capped and Free, and resistance being fragmented and shocked, the Free humans never really rallied and struck back in a co-ordinated way.

John Christopher had his central characters escape to Switzerland, which had closed borders, by hijacking an aircraft. On landing they had to prove they weren't Capped. As they leave the airport terminal, we hear shooting as of border guards massacring the Capped folks on the plane...

Eventually, Switzerland is invaded by a combined French and German army (what are the odds?)and swiftly overrun, largely due to the attackers' induced indifference to being killed or wounded. Given that this must have happened in other countries, the casualties must have been enormous.

I found the prequel totally creepy because I could see how it would most likely have worked. Before anyone in power realised that many of the people were being controlled, it was too late to organise any sort of defence against what were, in fact, their own people. Possibly the 'millions killed' and 'Great Cities crushed like anthills' mentioned in the original books were the result of local military commanders getting desperate and careless with nukes and napalm...chilling!

Whit sad old loser'd be thick enough to don thon get-up?

reply

Thanks guys

It wouldn't be so easy to invade Switzerland though. Not saying it's impossible but difficult with the Alps and does Switz have nukes to defend itself? Actually maybe that is what happened to it. I read in history books that even Hitler wanted to invade it but couldn't because of the Alps.

However it was a great series and books. I never thought about how the tripods took over but I suppose it's not how many were hypnotised but who i.e. politicians, military commanders etc.

reply

Oh, that's why that nut Hitler didn't do that. I always wondered.

reply

Yes, according to what Ozymandias tells Will in both the book and series, many people were killed. As to the ruined cities being off limits, in the book it says that when you got Capped, you were then thinking the cities were not allowed to be visited. The Cap was a brainwashing thing anyway.

As to the lands that were laid waste, in the third book it mentions that. That had to do with the fact that the Masters built three cities on Earth, which were considered the center parts of control. Now the Tripods could travel a great distance away from the cities, but there had to be limits, so I guess when the Masters took over the world and built the cities, they had to lay waste the areas that they couldn't build a city near so the Tripods could patrol it. I hope this makes sense.

reply

I just watched the Tv series for probably the 10th time... the final scene and the last words is amazing. Would I like a movie of these series? Yes. However, even more enjoyable would be to create the 3rd season, with all new actors continuing on from the end of the BBC series all those years ago. If possible, I would have cameos for the original actors too. This series is epic and stands the test of time.

reply