MovieChat Forums > The Winds of War (1983) Discussion > IF REMADE, WHO WOULD YOU CAST?

IF REMADE, WHO WOULD YOU CAST?


Well here's my first shot......

Commander Victor Henry- Ed Harris
Rhoda Henry- Judy Davis
Byron Henry- Paul Walker
Natalie Jastrow- Rachel Weisz
Dr. Aaron Jastrow- Christopher Plummer/Ian McKellan
Leslie Sloate- Hank Azaria
Warren Henry- Rick Schroeder
Janice L Henry- Reiko Aylesworth
Madeline Henry- Natasha Lyonne
Pam Tudsbury- Kate Beckinsale
Alaistar Tudsbury- Tom Wikinson
Dr. Fred Palmer Kirby- Kevin Spacey
Berel Jastrow- Gabriel Byrne
Avram Rabinowitz- Liev Schreiber

Adolf Hilter- Bruno Ganz
Reichsmarshal Hermann Goering- Brian Cox
Foreign Minister Von Ribbentropp- Wolf Kahler
SS Reichsfuhrer Himmler- Gary Oldman
Dr Josef Goebbels- Alan Cumming

General Armin Von Roon- Rutger Hauer
Lt. General Franz Halder- Ian Holm
Field Marshal Von Brauchitsch- Hanns Zischler
FM Von Rundstedt- Max Von Sydow
General Wilhelm Keitel- Kenneth Cranham
Major General Alfred Jodel- Michael Byrne
Admiral Raeder- David Scofield

President Franklin D Roosevelt- Jon Voight
Harry Hopkins- Ron Rifkin
Admiral Ernest J King- Philip Baker Hall
General George C Marshall- Ronny Cox
Admiral Preble- Dale Dye
Captain Red Tully- Stephen Root
General Fitzgerald- Michael O Neill
Secretary Cordell Hull- Kevin McCarthy
Secretary of War Stimson- Hal Holbrook
Admiral Kimmel- Kurtwood Smith
Lt Cmdr Carter Astor- Kiefer Sutherland
Admiral Leahy- Scott Wilson
Admiral William F Halsey- R Lee Ermey

Prime Minister Winston Churchill- Albert Finney
General Tillet- Daniel Craig
Air Marshal Hugh Dowding- Edward Fox
Commander Burne Wilke- Nigel Havers/Gerard Butler
Ted Gallard- Toby Stephens
Anthony Eden- Anthony Sher
Lord Halifax- Ian McDiarmid
Admiral Pound- Julian Glover
Ramsey- Bernard Hill

Josef Stalin- Rade Szerbezjia
General Yevlenko- Peter Stormare
Molotov- Zeljko Ivanek
Russian Soldier- Oleg Takaratov
Aircraft Spotter- Vladimir Mashkadov
Admiral Grachev- Olek Krupa
General Zhukov- Alexander Baluyev
Molotov-Zeljko Ivanek
Beria- Karel Roden
Russian Artillery Officer- Robert Vadim

Gestapo Agent/Lisbon/Rome- scar-face- Sylvester Groh
SS Officer Poland, Roster Officer- Justus Von Doyhani
General Guderian- Armin Mueller-Stahl
White hair Gestapo- Norbert Weisser
Captain of SS Bremen- Hardy Kruger
Wolf Pack Leader/Grobke- Thomas Kretschmann
Wolf Pack XO- Jochen Nickel
Army Major in Poland- Dominique Horowitz
Wolf Stoller- Jim Broadbent
Frau Stoller- Senta Berger

SO FAR.....










reply

Hi, I don't know if you will read this, as your message is a bit old, but I have very recently read the book and seen the miniseries and I have found some of your choices very interesting. Above all, I don't think it needs to be remade because it's, in my opinion, one of the best tv series ever. But let's play, here are my favourites from your choices:

Commander Victor Henry- Ed Harris
Dr. Aaron Jastrow- Christopher Plummer
Leslie Sloate- Hank Azaria
Kate Beckinsale- Pamela Tudsbury
Alaistar Tudsbury- Michael Caine
Berel Jastrow- Gabriel Byrne
Reichsmarshal Hermann Goering- Brian Cox
SS Reichsfuhrer Himmler- Gary Oldman
General Armin Von Roon- Rutger Hauer

Really well. I specially like the idea of Kate Beckinsale as Pamela, Azaria as Slote and Rutger Hauer as Armin Von Roon. Disagreements: I don't think Radha Mitchell neither Sadie Frost are good choices to play Natalie, because remember that Natalie is jew, and these two girls simply doesn't look jew. I don't know if Ali McGraw is, but she looked like and, although she was too old for the role, she did it pretty well. I think Rachel Weisz could be an option. Neither I like Kevin Spacey as Kirby, but I don't know why, maybe he is a bit too young fot the role. As for Adolph Hitler, I think Ian Mc Kellen would look far better than Jeremy Irons.

In case you read it, a little question: where in Winds of war does Beria appear? I can't remember (and I have seen the whole mini just a week ago). Maybe it's in its sequel, War and remembrance, which I haven't seen yet?

Regards,

Jordi

reply

Commander Victor Henry- Ed Harris
Rhoda Henry- Emma Thompson
Byron Henry- Christian Bale
Natalie Jastrow- Natalie Portman
Dr. Aaron Jastrow- Ian McKellen
Leslie Slote- Cillian Murphy
Warren Henry- James Franco
Janice L Henry- Scarlett Johansson
Madeline Henry- Natasha Lyonne
Pamela Tudsbury- Rachel Weisz
Alaistar Tudsbury- Michael Caine
Dr. Fred Palmer Kirby- Gary Oldman
Berel Jastrow- Gabriel Byrne

Adolf Hilter- Bruno Ganz
Reichsmarshal Hermann Goering- Brian Cox
Foreign Minister Von Ribbentropp- Udo Kier
SS Reichsfuhrer Himmler- Ulrich Noethen
Dr Josef Goebbels- Ulrich Matthes

General Armin Von Roon- Rutger Hauer
Lt. General Franz Halder- Christian Redl
Field Marshal Von Brauchitsch- Michael Mendl
General Wilhelm Keitel- Dieter Mann
Major General Alfred Jodel- Bill Corday
Admiral Raeder- Jurgen Prochnow

President Franklin D Roosevelt- Edward Herrmann
Harry Hopkins- Ron Rifkin
Admiral Ernest J King- Philip Baker Hall
General George C Marshall- Harve Presnell
Admiral Preble- Dale Dye
Captain Red Tully- Stephen Root
General Fitzgerald- Ed Lauter
Secretary Cordell Hull- Kevin McCarthy
Secretary of War Stimson- Hal Holbrook
Admiral Kimmel- Kurtwood Smith
Lt Cmdr Carter Astor- Josh Lucas
Admiral Leahy- Scott Wilson
Admiral William F Halsey- R Lee Ermey

Prime Minister Winston Churchill- Albert Finney
General Tillet- Julian Glover
Air Marshal Hugh Dowding- Christopher Plummer
Commander Burne Wilke- Paul Bettany
Ted Gallard- Charlie Hunnam
Anthony Eden- Anthony Sher
Lord Halifax- Michael Gough

Josef Stalin- Aleksandr Zbruev
General Yevlenko- Rade Sherbedgia
Colonel?????- Alexander Baluyev
Russian Soldier- Oleg Takaratov
Aircraft Spotter- Vladimir Mashkadov
Admiral Grachev- Olek Krupa
Russian Artillery Officer- Robert Vadim

Gestapo Agent/Lisbon/Rome- scar-face- Sylvester Groh
SS Officer Poland, Roster Officer- Justus Von Dohnanyi
General Guderian- Rolf Kanies
White hair Gestapo- Norbert Weisser
Wolf Pack Leader/Grobke- Thomas Kretschmann
Wolf Stoller- Gunther M Halmer
Frau Stoller- Senta Berger

reply

Bale is older then portman so the main jist of the Byran and Natalie problem would be diminished.

reply

Ted Gallard- Toby Stephens

Funny you should suggest him. His father was in War and Remembrance as Karl Rahm.

reply

don't know who I would cast as of yet but did anyone else notice that Alan Arkin played Stalin. His grandfather was russian.

reply

Saw your post just as I started rewatching the show. It looks a bit like Arkin, but it's not. It's Anatoly Chaguinian.

reply

For Grosse Admiral Erich Raeder, let's try Juergen Prochnow. Perhaps other possibilities for Juergen would be Feld Marschalls Erwin Rommel/Werner von Brauchitsch.

Nigel Havers/Russell Crowe as Major General Tillet, Royal Army.

Sky Dumont as Feld Marschall Gerd von Rundstest, or Jodl, or, possibly, Armin von Roon--an homage to the original.

For Hack Peters, let's try David James Elliot.

As an homage to the original, Hunter Schlesinger (little "Louis Henry"), could play Briny! Perhaps Elijah Wood as Briny?? Age Hunter's mug a bit, and he could also be Avram Rabinowitz.

Lance Henricksen as Ike. Alternately, Lance could play Admiral Spruance. Other possibilities for Spruance could be Chris Cooper/Kevin Costner/Matthew Modine.

Kevin could also do Admiral Chester Nimitz. As could Mark Harmon.

Robert Conrad as Breckinridge Long, Harry S. Truman, or Senator Lacouture.

Sean Astin as Warren's gunner, "Cornett".

Bentley Mitchum (as an homage to his grandfather) could play Warren's CAG.

Michael Weatherly/Max Martini/Matt Dillon/Jason London/Skeet Ulrich/Matthew Broderick/Matthew McConaughey as Lady Aster.

George Takei/Sam Watanabe/Takakura Ken as Admiral Yamamoto.

Gerald MacRainey/Michael Gaston/Charles Haid/Viggo Mortenssen as Captain Miles Browning.

Sir Ian McKellan/Tom Wilkinson/Sir Ian Holm as Alistair "Talky" Tudsbury.

Tom could possibly also do Hermann Goering.

Recycle Milton Johns as Dr. Karl Goerdeler, the leader of the '44 plot to kill Hitler.

Francisco Quinn/Billy Zane/David Straithairn as J. Robert Oppenheimer.

Patrick Labyourteaux as Bunky Thuston.

Robin Ellis ("Ross Plodark")/Robert Powell ("Jesus of Nazareth")/Ben Cross ("Chariots of Fire", "Dark Shadows--The Revival") as Field Marshall Bernard Law Montgomery.

Jeremy Black (the "Hitler Kids" from "The Boys from Brazil") as Adolf Hitler!

Michael Savage as Fred Fearing.

Robert Patrick as Russ Carton. Patrick could also perhaps play Admiral Husband E. Kimmel.

Catherine Bell/Patricia Heaton/Sela Ward/Lauren Holly as Rho.

Another possibility for Robert Patrick could be Dr. Palmer Kirby, as could be Mel Gibson/Patrick Duffy. Maybe even recycle Barry Bostwick as Palmer!!

Kate Winslet as Pamela.

Sean Murray/Steven Culp as Leslie Slote.

Josh Hartnett/Scott Foley/Kenneth Mitchell ("Eric Green", "Jericho") as Warren.

Robert Patrick/Gerald MacRainey as Admiral Jack "Jocko" Larkin possibilities.

Reese Witherspoon/Kirsten Dunst/Ashley Scott as Janice.

Leonard Nimoy/Bruce Weitz as Berel. Another possibility for Leonard would be as Dr. Aaron Jastrow. And still another homage to the original would be Topol as Dr. Jastrow.

Phillip Seymour-Hoffmann/Herbert Groenemeyer (the Nazi Naval War Correspondent from "Das Boot") as Dr. Werner Beck. Herbert could alternately play Heirich Himmler--or fatten him up, and he could be another Hermann Goering possibility.

Rutger Hauer/Wolf Kahler (The first Commandant of Theresienstadt, "Boerger", from the original "War and Remembrance") as Ribbentrop.

Martin Semmelrogge ("2nd Mate"/"No. 2", "Das Boot") as U-Boat Captain/Squadron Leader Priebke (aboard the "Bremen").

Jon Cypher/R. G. Armstrong as Admiral William Standley (Ret.).

Jonathin Frid as Ludwig Rosenthal (An homage to his former producer, from his "Dark Shadows" days.). Mr. Frid could be another Admiral Standley possibility.

Joanna Going/Terri Hatcher/Winona Ryder as Natalie/Selma Ascher, with Alicia Coppola only, as Selma Ascher.

John M. Jackson/Sam Elliot/Daniel J. Travanti/James B. Sikking/Keith Carradine as Admiral Ernest King.

Steven Berkoff (Now, where have we heard THAT name before??); this time, as Soviet Admiral Gorshev!

Bill Smitrovitch as General "Moose" Fitzgerald.

Robert DiNiro/Chris Mitchum (an homage to ol' Dad)/James Mitchum (another homage to ol'Dad)/Stacy Keach as Pug.

Liv Tyler/Brittany Tiplady/Pauley Perette as Madeliene Henry Anderson.

Leonardo DiCaprio as Simon Anderson, Madeliene's husband.

Tom Beringer/Mel Gibson/Robert Vaughn/Ben Murphy ("Warren", from "The Winds of War") as FDR. Jane Alexander reprises again--thirty years later, as Eleanor Roosevelt. Another Eleanor possibility, with appropriate makeup, would be Meghan Gallagher.

Rush Limbaugh as Hugh Cleveland!

Ralph Fiennes plays SS Major Karl Rahm. And Uwe Ochsenkneckt (the assistant CPO from "Das Boot") as his aide, Haindl.

Jason Isaacs plays Eichmann. With brown contacts, Jason could also do Dr. Goebbels. Still another possibility for Jason would be Philip Rule.

Joaquin Phoenix as SS Maj. Blobel, or Auschwitz Commandant Rudolph Hoess.

Randy Quaid/Tom Sizemore/Michael Madsen/R. Lee Ermey as Bull Halsey.

Terry O'Quinn as General Omar Bradley. Terry could be an Ike possibility.

Peter Outerbridge ("Millennium") is another Admiral Spruance possibility.

Adam Goldberg/Jonathan Silverman as Udam. These two could be Berel possibilities.

Say, I'd be really interested to see how Seinfeld would do in serious drama. Try him . . . as Berel!!

Hristo Shopov ("Pontius Pilate", "The Passion of the Christ") as General Yevlenko.

Hubertus Bengsch (the "First Mate/XO/No. 1", "Das Boot")/Helmut Greim as Wolf Stoller.

Billy Boyd as British Meteorologist J.M. Stagg.

With judicious makeup, and, shave his head, Chuck Norris as General Patton!

Sir Anthony Hopkins/Edward Woodward ("The Equalizer")/Kevin McNally ("Poldark") as Winston Leonard Spencer Churchill!

Dominic Monaghan as RAF ace, Ted Gallard, Pam's boyfriend.

Anther possibility for Robert Patrick would be Consul General Jim Gaither.

Kristen Cloke ("Dr. Lara Means", "Millennium")/Jane Seymour (AGAIN!!) as the Comtesse de Chambrun.

Timothy Dalton/Richard Morant ("Dr. Ennys I", "Poldark")/Michael Cadman ("Dr. Ennys II", "Poldark")/Sean Bean/David Wenham/James Aubrey/John Duttine/Simon Williams ("James Bellamy" from "Upstairs, Downstairs") as Air Commander/Marshall/Lord Bourne-Wilke.

Other possibilities for Gerald MacRainey include Admiral Leahy, Ike, or General Omar Bradley.

Stephen James Lang/Randy Quaid/Wings Hauser as General Leslie Groves.

And Al Pacino in a cameo as Enrico Fermi.

reply

Commander Victor Henry- Leslie Nielsen
Byron Henry- Jason Priestley
Natalie Jastrow- Beverly Polcyn
Berel Jastrow- Will Ferrell

Pamela Tudsbury- Dakota Fanning

Adolf Hilter- Mel Brooks
Reichsmarshal Hermann Goering- Arnold Schwarzenegger

General Armin Von Roon- David Hasselhoff

President Franklin D Roosevelt- John Travolta

Prime Minister Winston Churchill- John Goodman

Josef Stalin- Danny Glover

Gestapo Agent/Lisbon/Rome- scar-face- Mike Myers

reply

Wow...way back in '05, you sure had a lot of time on your hands...

reply